Hey all...just wanted to get everyone's opinion on who I should keep at wideout. We're in a 12-team, 4 keeper league, and keepers aren't due 'til around August, so this isn't really a pressing issue. Other than the WR spot, I've got P. Manning, FWP and Ronnie Brown who will probably carry over into my '07 roster. The two WRs I have to decide between are Roy Williams and T.J. Houshmandzadeh. Scoring is PPR, 1 pt/10 yards rec/rush, -2 for turnovers.
T.J. - #9 receiver: 90 rec. for 1081 yds, 9 TDs; 245 points in 14 games (17.5 avg)
Roy - #10 receiver: 82 rec. for 1310 yds, 7 TDs; 243 points in 16 games (14.5 avg)
As you can see, they're just about dead even in points. Roy had more yards, and is a true #1 receiver with more YPC. TJ, however, has more catches, more TDs, and a better average in two less games. In fact, TJ's average PPG is third in our league behind Marvelous Marvin and Steve Smith (18.4 and 18.0, respectively). Plus, there's the added utility from having a Bengal on my roster, being a homer and all. On my personal crank score calculator, TJ's crank for '06 was 63.75; Roy's, 45.35.
In my boat, do you protect T.J. or Roy? Thanks in advance for the input and Happy New Year to all!