Should I make this preseason trade or not?

[markveit 0]

Ok, complicated keeper league...I will just list my possible options and please let me know which option looks better, to build not only for this year but the future also...Other notable keepers who can not be drafted...lamont jordan, steve smith, jason whitten, frank gore, larry johnson, antonio gates, and a few others i can't remember now...

 

scenario 1 (red denotes my keepers and the rounds I get to keep them in)

I have pipck number 10 out of 12...

 

1.10

2.03

3.10

4. JULIUS JONES

5.10

6.

7.

8.

9.

10.

11. WILLIE PARKER (will be my 8th round pick next year)

12.

13.

14.

15.

**********************************************

scenario 2

 

I can trade my first and fifth round pick to aquire mcgahee as a 6th rounder this year as well as another 14th and 15th pick...so i would get him in the 6th this year, and i can keep him in the 3rd next year. so going into the draft i would look like this...

 

1 NO PICK

2.3

3.10

4 JULIUS JONES

5 NO PICK

6 WILLIS MCGAHEE (would be my third round pick next year)

7

8

9

10

11 WILLIE PARKER (will be my 8th round pick next year)

12

13

14

14

15

15

***************************************************************************

 

scenario 3 (only happens if I do scenario 2) I can trade julius jones for another 2nd round pick this year. so i will look like this going into draft.

 

1 NO PICK

2.3

2.11

3.11

4 NO PICK

5 NO PICK

6 WILLIS MCGAHEE

7

8

9

10

11 WILLIE PARKER

12

13

14

14

15

15

*****************************************************************************

Kind of confusing...basically which scenario would you rather have going into the draft with the 10th pick...Thanks in advance.