Trading for Peyton or Palmer--Too Much?

[kcBlitzkrieg 29]

Im working on a deal for either Peyton or Palmer. TD heavy league, have to start 2 QBs. I already have McNabb but my #2 is not so strong. As you'll see, Im pretty strong in other spots. I don't need to make a move now but Id like to ship Stallworth while his value is high. I like Portis but out of the 3 stud RBs I have I think his value is the lowest due to the possiblity of him not finishing the season.

My RBs are R.Brown,Rudi,Portis

WRs are Holt/Chambers/Plaxico

Droughns & Stallworth are on bench.

 

Offer is Peyton for Portis/Rudi & Big Ben/Stallworth.

or

Palmer for Portis/Rudi straight up.

 

Which one, if either would you pull the trigger on?

[kcBlitzkrieg 29]

...bump.

[urmother 0]

i think you might be offering a little bit too much. i'd go peyton for rudi or portis straight up. if you want to include stallworth or trade for palmer get a little extra value back. palmer still has some ??? marks this early on his new legs.

 

 

hook a brotha up -- http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=233200

[Sopranos 0]

I wouldn't let Rudi go for nobody! I think he is going to have a monster year.....and, he does not share goal line carries.

 

If you have to, trade portis and Stallworth for Peyton and hang on to Rudi.

 

Good luck!

[bobpate17 0]

U r offering way too much. two stu RBs for one stud QB. too much. I say offer rudi and stallworth for manning and portis/ stallworth for palmer.

 

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.php?showforum=13

[IndyFan 2]

Portis straight up for Palmer is the way I would go. Droughns is a fill in for bye weeks and Portis is in for a long year with shared carries at the goal line with Duckett.