good and bad for good and great?

[The Hunter 0]

standard scoring 12 team league. start qb, rb, rb, wr, wr, wr/rb, te, k, def/st

 

my team:

qb - chad pennington, mark brunell

rb - shaun alexander, chester taylor, warrick dunn, maurice morris, jerious norwood, brandon jacobs

wr - larry fitzgerald, t.j. houshmandzadeh, keyshawn johnson, joey galloway, jerricho cotchery, bryant johnson

te - l.j. smith

def - buffalo bills

k - none (i'll pick one up before the end of the week)

 

his team:

qb - michael vick, marc bulger

rb - tatum bell, willie parker, leon washington, reuben droughns, ron dayne

wr - marvin harrison, javon walker, mike furrey, greg jennings, chris henry

te - eric johnson, desmond clark

def - philly eagles

k - matt stover

 

he has offered me either:

marc bulger and marvin harrison for chester taylor and jerricho cotchery.

or

marc bulger, marvin harrison and reuben droughns for chester taylor and joey galloway.

 

what do you think? should i look to add players, or am i crazy for even considering?

[Beef Ravioli 0]

I wouldn't do it. I think you do not strengthen your team in a crucial areas. I think you weaken your RB's to much.

 

Thanks for mine

[hawkvike 0]

I am in a league where we start two QB's, so it is hard for me to switch gears...in our league you would be ripping him off HUGE!!! However, in your league you may hurt yourself unless Alexander gets back soon. I would still make the second deal. Huge upgrade at WR...huge upgrade at QB...downgrade at RB. Thanks for your help.

[T Man 0]

I would really do this deal.

 

I like the first option.

Nice deal jump on it!!!

 

 

 

please see mine

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=243438

[BrianReilly55 0]

Don't like either of them. With Shaun A's situation still uncertain, Taylor is really your one thing you can count on(well, more or less) in your backfield. You can certainly use the upgrade at QB and now, sadly, at WR. Double injury whammy-Shaun and Fitz, ouch! I'm feeling the same pain, brother!

 

Guess it also depends on your record, you know? Anyhow, I'd not pull the trigger. My 2 cents...

 

Sorry for my delayed response. I was called away from computer yesterday(damn work obligations!), and am now just getting back to things here. Thanks for your help on mine!

[Illini4evr 0]

Horrible deal. Pennington is going to be sitting in a 75% pass role for pretty much the entire season. You'd be losing your only main back until SA is back and be getting what???...another QB and reciever that you won't need down the line. I'd say giving up your RB situation to laterally help your QB and laterally help your WR spot is not smart. Instead of asking for a QB from him try swapping out for one of his RB's and then instead of offering Chester try offering another reciever or possibly a lower back. That is your best option but my main recommendation is do nothing.

[bobpate17 0]

I like secon deal the best. U get great WR and QB. and u can use morris in place of SA and u can use Dunn always. and dragoun will give u good back up RB. I got harrison and gave up driver and Wayne couple of days ago. I think harrison is worth it.

 

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=243742

[mgm32 0]

I like the deal. Do it ASAP. When Alexander is healthy you will be set at RB and QB.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...p;#entry2774744