My Addai and Roy Will for his Portis and Evans?

[enjoi525 0]

OK so this offer seems really good to me, but I'm thinking do I really need to do this? I am pretty good at RB but a little weak at WR. I have the best record in the league but the guy in 4th place has a pretty mean team that he has put together through some trades and I see myself playing him in the championship. The guy I am trying to trade with has stated this is his final offer so it's take it or leave it. I know I can possibly swing 1 of my other RBs after this trade but the deadline is next Fri to the chances of that are not too high.

 

EDIT: This is TD heavy. All TDs 6 points, rushing and rec yards = 20 yards per point.

 

My Team:

Delhomme

Romo

LT

Ronnie Brown

Ahman Green

Jamal Lewis

Addai

Randy Moss

Roy Williams

L. Coles

Muhammed

Terry Glenn

Cooley

 

His Team (the guy im trading with not contending for the title with)

Huard

Leftwhich

Portis

Westbrook

Henry

Bush

J. Walker

TO

Furrey

Evans

Daniels

Franks

 

So do I take it or do I leave it?

Leave a link and i'll answer yours.

[vjjjc 0]

I wouldn't do it... roy is your best reciver and adai is coming on... Evans is nothing... Portis is nice but I think roy and Addai will out perform Portis and any other receiver you have to play in roy's place.

 

 

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=252252

[Swagger 0]

Keep Addai & Roy you are fine at RB, heck Ronnie is coming on himself and LT just is flat sick....Mine

[dalie 2]

Keep Addai and Roy, you are LOADED at RB but weak at WR and would get weaker if you do it.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=252219

[nemode 0]

OK so this offer seems really good to me, but I'm thinking do I really need to do this? I am pretty good at RB but a little weak at WR. I have the best record in the league but the guy in 4th place has a pretty mean team that he has put together through some trades and I see myself playing him in the championship. The guy I am trying to trade with has stated this is his final offer so it's take it or leave it. I know I can possibly swing 1 of my other RBs after this trade but the deadline is next Fri to the chances of that are not too high.

 

EDIT: This is TD heavy. All TDs 6 points, rushing and rec yards = 20 yards per point.

 

My Team:

Delhomme

Romo

LT

Ronnie Brown

Ahman Green

Jamal Lewis

Addai

Randy Moss

Roy Williams

L. Coles

Muhammed

Terry Glenn

Cooley

 

His Team (the guy im trading with not contending for the title with)

Huard

Leftwhich

Portis

Westbrook

Henry

Bush

J. Walker

TO

Furrey

Evans

Daniels

Franks

 

So do I take it or do I leave it?

Leave a link and i'll answer yours.

 

 

I would do it. POrtis is going to start getting more carries with moss out and being healthy. That means big time production....

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=252262

[gunnergip 0]

I would do the trade...i own both evans and portis in one of my leagues...dont mind it at all and am not nearly as deep as you are at wide receiver (i have moss, evans cotchery and reggie williams)..you still retain coles and get evans, but here is the trick...i would then trade ronnie brown away for a receiver...maybe package him with another receiver...im sure someone would take a starting back off your hands.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...p;#entry2848327

[jdjacks10 0]

Don't do it- Roy is not only ur best wr but ur pretty stack at rb as u have ronnie brown, green is good when healthy, and J. Lewis isnt a bad option either. I would look into maybe trading one of ur rb and wr to upgrade ur WR spot to get Roy some help.

[mackgeescott 0]

BIG NO! Your stacked already at RB, and Roy will continue his numbers with Martz calling the plays in DET. Maybe swing Brown ot Green for a top tier WR, but it had better be a big name. If nothing else stay put, I can see that team winning a championship..

 

Mine:

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=252280

[manola 0]

I'd absolutely stick with what you've got!

 

I'd rather have Addai and Roy any day!

 

 

 

Please see mine:

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=252284

[megan 0]

have to agree with practically everyone above, that would be a biggg mistake.

just keep patient, williams and addai will do you well.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=252255

[footballfanatics 0]

You have a pretty good squad stay with it.

[Hamstring 0]

I don't think you benefit at all from this trade since you are already stacked at RB and relatively weak at WR. Deal one of those backs for a nice complement to ROY.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=252285

[Candygram4Mongo 8]

What are you smokin?

 

Do not make this trade.

Roy is your man, and Addai has his best days ahead.

 

Portis is a step up over Addai, but Addai plays with a superior offense.

Evans is big step down from Roy.

 

see mine pleez

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=252283

[bunnerjk 0]

I would stay put as well. Your WR's take a huge hit!!!!!!!

[P Park Pimps 1]

Don't do it. You say you need help at WR then why would you trade your best receiver??? I think your team is fine the way it is.

 

Thanx for replying to mine.

[FantasyPhenom 0]

U'll be fine with what u got.Addai is gettin much better and is on the best offensive teams in football.

[-bp- 0]

The trade doesn't do much for you...I say no.

[The Hunter 0]

just say no and keep what you got.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=252307

[time to get ill 0]

I'm gonna have to agree and say keep Addai and Williams. Your keeping a top 5 WR and Addai's stats will only get better in the coming weeks, Dominic who? Addai's the man. Keep what u got. Good Luck?

 

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=252027

[LLcoolJ 0]

Definiately stick with what you have. I like Roy and Addai (getting more touches every week) way better.