Battle of the Second Rate starting QBs

[joeunleaded 0]

Here's the deal:

 

Our league drafts rd 1 - 15, then two wildcard rounds. Regardless of position, one of those two wildcards must play each week. (Can't swap from regular roster.)

 

My two are

- Jason Campbell at home vs MIA

- David Gerrard at home vs TEN

 

Who should I start in Week 1?

 

Both DEF's are close IMHO.

 

Both QBs are a great talent and ABOUT the same experience. Both have the legs to get some yds.

 

Gerrard's got a better running game with FTaylor and MJD, Campbell's got a better passing game with Randle El and S Moss.

 

I've got Gerrrard to start since I think the MIA pass rush is SLIGHTLY tougher... HELP?

 

Leave your link - I'll answer.

[Beef Ravioli 0]

I think Garrard is your safe play and Campbell may go either way - very good to very bad. I believe I would start with Garrard and see how Campbell does for a week or two.

 

Here's mine

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=284031

[primaryknockers 0]

I would go w/Garrard simply based on more experience---But I think your solid with both guys really......Thanks for mine

[Nomad99 483]

I think you have to go with Garrard here.....Experience counts

[Lake Show 0]

I will go against the grain and say Campbell. 3 years less exp. but still did a nice job for the last 6 or so games he played. He now has another year under off. coord and that should pay dividends.