Rate this trade...

[YesNoMaybe 0]

12 team...standard Yahoo....no PPR

 

TEAM A

SJax and B. Marshall

 

for

 

TEAM B

McGahee and LFitz

 

Teams would then be...

 

TEAM A

 

Palmer/Randy Moss/LFitz/B. Edwards/jacoby Jones/Muss/McGahee/Jacobs/J. Lewis/F. Taylor/V. Davis

 

TEAM B

 

Kitna/Wayne/Reggie Brown/Jennings/Crayton/Marshall/Henderson/Henry/SJax/Norwood/Turner/Watson/E. Johnson

 

who makes out better with this trade????

 

Leave link and I'll answer yours......

[PatrickT 0]

If I'm team A, I don' t make this trade. I think both mcgahee is major downgrade from sjax, and fitz is not that big of an upgrade over Marshall, if he's an upgrade at all.

[Rerun 0]

SJax greatly outweighs any slight diggerence in WR.

 

Please see mine

[Big Pauly 0]

One more vote for keepin SJax and Marshall. Jackson's value is only going to go up from here (Pace being out, poor performance week one). Also, while Fitz will get his... that Arizona passing game looked awful on Monday night.

 

Thanks for mine.

[DrGonzo 1]

No way i trade away SJAX for that

 

See Mine

[rdub15 0]

i agree...do not do this trade. mcgahee and fitz are not the gamebreaker that SJax is..he's too good and you shouldn't let him go. he won me my league last year and despite his week 1 performance, he'll put up great numbers. thanks for mine.

[WoodDuck2003 0]

I agree, S.Jax/Marshall way better than McGahee/Fitz. The drop from S.Jax to McGahee is a lot bigger than the increase for Marshall to Fitz. Marshall actually has a fairly good chance to be a very solid #2 fantasy WR on a solid team.

 

Team A needs to hang tight.

 

Thanks for seeing mine.