S. Smith for F. Gore

[shamrock_94 0]

I have been offered the following:

 

F. Gore and V. Jackson

for

S. Smith and S. Jackson

 

Would you take this deal

 

Here is the rest of my team

QB - Romo, Griese (start 1)

WR - M. Harrison, B. Edwards, B. Engram, (S. Smith) (Start 3)

RB - E. James, B. Leonard, S. Morris, K. Watson, K. Jones (S. Jackson) (Start 2)

TE - K. Winslow

 

Scoring: 1pt/20 yds rush/rec, 1 pt/50 yds pass, 6pts/ TD

 

I may be able to convince the other owner to give up Calvin Johnson instead of V. Jackson, or try for Smith for Gore straight up.

 

Let me know what you think

[axels08 0]

yes, i would trade for gore especially if you could get calvin. you have good wrs already and could use a stud rb

 

 

not sure with just vincent jackson

 

if you were able to get leonard then not so sure but i take it you did not.

 

gore and calvin for smith and jax i would do

 

please answer mine

[Kemosobe 1]

I agree.. only if you can get Calvin... You lose only a little at WR and gain alot at RB atleast wit jax injuries

[tazman01 0]

I would only do the deal if it was calvin and NOT V Jackson. Let's not forget Delhoum is out, c.b for a few weeks and Carr doesn't throw a great deep ball.

Good luck with the trade and let us know the outcome.

Thanks for mine.

[da browns 10]

I have been offered the following:

 

F. Gore and V. Jackson

for

S. Smith and S. Jackson

 

Would you take this deal

 

Here is the rest of my team

QB - Romo, Griese (start 1)

WR - M. Harrison, B. Edwards, B. Engram, (S. Smith) (Start 3)

RB - E. James, B. Leonard, S. Morris, K. Watson, K. Jones (S. Jackson) (Start 2)

TE - K. Winslow

 

Scoring: 1pt/20 yds rush/rec, 1 pt/50 yds pass, 6pts/ TD

 

I may be able to convince the other owner to give up Calvin Johnson instead of V. Jackson, or try for Smith for Gore straight up.

 

Let me know what you think

[da browns 10]

with Calvin, Absolutely!

 

S-Jax will be "tender" for a whjile and his line isn't helping him.

[DandyRandy 0]

I would do the trade, for S.Jax will not out perform F.Gore the rest of the season.

thanks for answering mine.

[HowieWan 0]

I would NOT do this trade for the following reasons:

 

1) Steve Smith is the best WR in fantasy football. Delhomme or Carr, losing him makes your WR corp a weakness rather than a strength.

2) Gore is suffering as much as Jackson from being part of an anemic offense. He is not a serious upgrade from Jackson, and if you are giving up Smith you need a serious upgrade.

3) You are building a team for the end of the season. Why sell low on Jackson and fears that Smith will suffer with Delhomme out?

 

Rather than this trade, if you really want to move Jackson, I would package him with Edwards and aim at somebody like Portis. Or try to trade Jackson for Lamont Jordan straight up. Because you start 3 WRs, it makes no sense to compromise the huge advantage you have with 2 of the top 5 WRs.

[bno70_1 0]

Are you getting Smith and S Jackson, or getting rid of them?

 

I would vote for the side getting those two. Big time.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=291998

[Coalter 0]

I would not do that trade. S Smith is a scoring machine and SJAX is ready to play already according to some of my friends that live in STL.

[JGB_11 0]

I would do the trade only if you get a better upgrade at WR.

 

Other than that Smith is a beast, so I would hold onto him.

[electricrelish 0]

I would not do this trade.

 

Right now, I think S. Jackson and F. Gore are about equal. You end up getting a worse WR. I don't like this trade. I think you're better off with what you have now.

 

See mine:

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=292086