Keeper Trade

[SteelerFan80 0]

Would you trade DeAngelo Williams and Ryan Grant for Joseph Addai and Cedric Benson?

 

My thought is Williams > Benson (especially if rumors hold true of Carolina dumping Foster) and Addai > Grant. Still, I want opinions.

 

Thanks!

[Little Big Head 6]

Im high on Grant, but Id go for the trade if it gets you addai. DW is a slightly more valuable than Benson imo(very debatable), but not enough to stop me from pulling the trigger

[oban14 0]

Would you trade DeAngelo Williams and Ryan Grant for Joseph Addai and Cedric Benson?

 

My thought is Williams > Benson (especially if rumors hold true of Carolina dumping Foster) and Addai > Grant. Still, I want opinions.

 

Thanks!

 

I agree with the second poster. Tough call but Addai is in a better system and should be a top 5 pick this year and the next several years. Grant is probably a second round pick at this point.

 

I'm not crazy about Benson or Williams, so they're a wash. If Foster goes, Williams goes up in value. If Turner is signed by Chicago, Benson tanks in value.