3 HOT QBs: which one to trade?

[rwren 4]

I have McNabb, Rivers, and Warner so I would like to trade one, but I'm not sure that I even need to with my current lineup.

 

My lineup is Mcnabb/Rivers/or Warner (matchups)

Wayne, S Moss or Welker

Peterson, Turner, Jacobs (DeWill, Maroney, MBush, AHall, on bench)

ODaniels

Prater

Tenn.

 

I'd like to upgrade my TE or WR2. Do any of these trades sound fair?

 

1. Warner for S.Smith

2. Rivers and S.Moss for Marshall and Palmer

3. Warner for D. Clark

 

1. The guy who has Smith isn't hurting at QB, he has Delhomme and A Rodgers but he has Housh and AJohnson already as WRs.

2. The 2nd guy is 2-0 with Palmer sucking. I think I could entice him with Rivers but I don't know if he would downgrade from Marshall to SMoss. I'm not sure if this would be smart for me.

3. I guess D. Clark is coming back from his injury. Would that be a huge upgrade over Daniels? I'm thinking Clark might not repeat last year because of AGonzalez improvement.

 

 

OR.....I could just hang on to all 3 QBs because all 3 probably won't maintain this all season. Besides McNabb and Warner have injury histories.

[tazman01 0]

I have McNabb, Rivers, and Warner so I would like to trade one, but I'm not sure that I even need to with my current lineup.

 

My lineup is Mcnabb/Rivers/or Warner (matchups)

Wayne, S Moss or Welker

Peterson, Turner, Jacobs (DeWill, Maroney, MBush, AHall, on bench)

ODaniels

Prater

Tenn.

 

I'd like to upgrade my TE or WR2. Do any of these trades sound fair?

 

1. Warner for S.Smith

2. Rivers and S.Moss for Marshall and Palmer

3. Warner for D. Clark

 

1. The guy who has Smith isn't hurting at QB, he has Delhomme and A Rodgers but he has Housh and AJohnson already as WRs.

2. The 2nd guy is 2-0 with Palmer sucking. I think I could entice him with Rivers but I don't know if he would downgrade from Marshall to SMoss. I'm not sure if this would be smart for me.

3. I guess D. Clark is coming back from his injury. Would that be a huge upgrade over Daniels? I'm thinking Clark might not repeat last year because of AGonzalez improvement.

OR.....I could just hang on to all 3 QBs because all 3 probably won't maintain this all season. Besides McNabb and Warner have injury histories.

 

Thanks for mine. I would do Warner for S Smith if you could pull that one off - Smith will be there all year, warner, well, Leinart c/b starter at some point this year.

2. Rivers and moss is another possibility, though I'm not big on Palmer, I'm huge on Marshall

3. I'm not big on Clark

 

Daniels s/b decent at TE I would go with Smith first or Marshall second, but wouldn't do the 3rd deal at all. I love both Smith and Marshall - anytime you can get a stud - its money.