Been offered 2 seperate deals.. Which do I make?

[ampheels 3]

12 team non ppr.. 2 rb/ 3 wr/ flex

 

current roster:

 

qb- rodgers

rb- CJ/ Rice/ Slaton/ Bradshaw/ Maroney/ Felix/ Choice

wr- Djax/ Miles Austin/ Hester/ Manningham/ Massaqoui/ A. Gonzalez

te- carlson/ olsen

de- cowboys

 

been offered:

 

receiving: Sid Rice/ Tony G/ Mcgahee/ Jets Defense----for---- Bradshaw/Manningham/A. Gonzalez/ Carlson

 

or

 

receiving: Driver/ Cards Defense----for---- Bradshaw/ A. Gonzalez

 

 

what do yall think?... leave your link

[nor73 0]

I would absolutely do the first deal. You're basically getting S.Rice (Favre's favorite target and a top 5 WR the last few weeks); Gonzo (a top 10 TE); and a top 10 D in the Jets for one player... Bradshaw (who splits carries with B.Jacobs). A.Gonzalez is coming back from an injury and will be the 3rd or 4th option for Manning at best - Wayne, Clark, and maybe even Collie/Garcon being ahead of him.

 

Take the deal. You get some needed WR help with Rice and you upgrade at TE and Def. And, if McGahee goes back to vulturing TDs from R.Rice, like he was for the first 4-5 weeks of the season... are you kidding me? You're making out like a bandit.

 

Good luck.

[surfnturf3g01 0]

Oh man, do that first deal in a heartbeat. Not even close in my opinion...

 

Thanks for mine!

[ampheels 3]

thanks for the input.. i agree with deal # 1 being better in my opinion, i don't think the driver deal is too bad either.. but i think im getting the kings ransom in deal # 1 lol

 

i'll look like this post trade:

 

rb- CJ/Rice/ Slaton/ Maroney/ Mcgahee/ Felix/ Choice (who ill drop for another wideout)

Wr- Djax/ Sid Rice/ Miles Austin/ Hester/ Massqoui

te- Tony G/ Olsen

de- Jets / Cowboys (both have 1 strong matchup in weeks 14-16)

[macho tony 0]

I'd pull the trigger on both trades.

[Larry David 20]

Both deals are good but I would also go with trade #1.

 

Here's mine.....

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=355270

[falconfan22 0]

Trade # 1 definitely!

[PSILOCYBIN 0]

You may have decided by now, but I agree with the consensus and that is trade # 1.

[ampheels 3]

thanks for the input everyone.. i got the owner to include donnie avery for me throwing in massaqoui

 

final trade looked like this...

 

sending : bradshaw/manningham/ a. gonzalez/ carlson/ massaqoui

 

receiving: sid rice/ tony gonzalez/ mcgahee( i'm a rice owner)/ donnie avery/ jets defense

[Bills Buff 1]

thanks for the input everyone.. i got the owner to include donnie avery for me throwing in massaqoui

 

final trade looked like this...

 

sending : bradshaw/manningham/ a. gonzalez/ carlson/ massaqoui

 

receiving: sid rice/ tony gonzalez/ mcgahee( i'm a rice owner)/ donnie avery/ jets defense

 

You got a steal. He must be a Giants fan.

[ampheels 3]

You got a steal. He must be a Giants fan.

 

actually is a Pittsburgh guy...

 

going to try to flip olsen and tashard choice for a slight upgrade with more upside at RB... and then add Fred Davis off the wire