Trade Help!?

[drewez44 0]

Hey Guys my league is start 1Qb 2Rb 3 Wr 1 Te

 

I have Gore and Foster as my starting RBs my Wrs are very weak with Floyd being the best.Addai is my back-up Rb.

Should i Trade Addai MFloyd JFinley for Calvin Johnson Mark Clayton Tony Gonzalez and J Harrison?

 

My starting lineup now looks like

Qb Brady

Rb Gore

Rb Foster

Wr Floyd

Wr B Loyd

Wr D Mason or M Williams (SEA) or J Jones (HOU)

Te J Finley

 

back-up RB Addai

 

 

My starting line-up would look like

Qb Brady

Rb Gore

Rb Foster

Wr Calv Johnson

Wr MClayton

Wr B Lloyd

Te Tony Gonzalez

 

back-up Rb J Harrison

 

Any help aprreciated and I will answer yours!

[drewez44 0]

Ill answer yours!!!! bump

[chrisfab 0]

not a huge fan of 4 player trades, but i think i'd stay put.

 

Do you really want to rely on Harrison during byes or injuries?

 

Thanks for answering mine.

[drewez44 0]

bump

[Bearnut 0]

That's a lot of people to trade. I think trades are better if they are no more than 2 for 2, or maybe 2 for 3 if one side has better players.

 

That said, I really just don't see that the trade really helps you that much.

[irish2007 0]

id stay put too. thats a lot of people involved. the guys youd get in return wouldnt help you much.

[MRclutch4 0]

Thanks for answering mine.

I don't think you should do that trade. Keep your players. Overall, i think your side of the trade is better.

[Adamr2na 0]

I'd also stick with what you have now.

[Axe Elf 0]

Five replies and not a single sensible comment among them... You guys are SO lucky I'm here.

 

YES! You do that deal--I'd just be surprised if he would accept your collection of smegma for the quality players you are requesting.

 

Your starting RBs don't change, and having Harrison instead of Addai at the backup position isn't THAT much of a downgrade in performance. In fact, Harrison is a better scheduling option since Addai shares a bye with Foster.

 

Your starting WRs go from a collection of second and third tier guys, Floyd, Lloyd and Mason, to three solid WR1s--Calvin Johnson, Mark Clayton, and Mike Williams. (Yeah, ok, Williams was already on your team, you were just failing to start him.)

 

Maybe you lose a coupla points a week at TE, but what you gained at WR is BY FAR worth it!

 

Sometimes I can't believe I'm the only one who realizes these things, but then, that's why I'm Axe Elf, and you're not.

[TeamChaches 0]

I could not agree more with AXE ELF.

 

Pull the trigger on that trade

 

Detroit Homer here and I won't be shocked if Calvin gets 12+ looks this week.