Tiki or Cadillac in a keeper league?

[Larry David 20]

I have a chance to trade Cadillac Williams for Tiki Barber. Keep in mind that it is a keeper league so even though Caddy's situation is terrible right now, he will probably be a starter long after Tiki retires. I have a "win now" team so I don't mind taking a gamble on a veteran, but will I regret it three years from now?

 

Tiki or Cadillac in a keeper league. What would you do?

[bkros42 0]

i think you were confused in mine.. im GETTING holt for those 2.. please reconsider your response

 

 

as for your question, what are your other RB's and team look like... this would help

 

id want to do it aswell, but with chances of him retiring soon/getting hurt with jacobs breathing down his neck, id prolly keep caddy... my .02

 

 

mine:

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=240906

[Larry David 20]

i think you were confused in mine.. im GETTING holt for those 2.. please reconsider your response

as for your question, what are your other RB's and team look like... this would help

 

id want to do it aswell, but with chances of him retiring soon/getting hurt with jacobs breathing down his neck, id prolly keep caddy... my .02

mine:

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=240906

 

I caught my mistake after I posted and corrected it.

 

The only other decent RB I have is McGahee. But I have Peyton Manning at QB and a very strong WR corp.

[ramblin'wreck 0]

For a keeper league, I would keep Caddy. I even think he will turn around as early as this season.

 

 

Here is mine.

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=240855

[strangebrew 0]

it's sad but i'd keep caddy since you are a keeper. thx for helping with mine.

[Seattle Schmitty 0]

I'd have to know your team and how many guys you keep. I have Caddy in a keeper and I'm hoping he'll still be good to keep for next year but I only keep three so there may not be room for him.

 

thanks for mine

[Cougars77 0]

Keep Caddy. You would regret it next year or the year after, which is why I HATE keeper leagues.