2 trade options involving Vick, Favre...

[hagler 0]

I have:

 

Vick, Frye

Portis/Betts, J.Jones,A.Green, Droughns

Djack, Coles, Mason, Reggie Williams

Watson

 

 

First Offer:

Favre, J.Norwood, Driver

for

Frye, Reggie Williams, A.Green

 

Second Offer:

Brady, Pennington, Mushin Muhammad, Pittman

for

Vick,Frye,Mason, Droughns

 

Which one does my team get Better?

#1

Favre, Vick

Portis/Jones/Droughns/Norwood

Djack/Coles/Driver/Mason

 

#2

Brady,Pennington

Portis/Jones/A.Green/Pittman----pick up Herron for Green

Djack/Coles/Muhammad/Reggie Williams

 

Please help----I'LL ANSWER YOURS!

[Triumph 0]

Pull the trigger on # 2. Brady is more consistant than Vick, Muhammad will hook you up and Pittman well he is what he is. Don't dump green, keep him for sure.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=242890 I need to know if its fair as well. Would you Veto?

[hagler 0]

BUMP

[Football Fan 20 2]

I'd stand on what you have, you're not getting much for what you're giving away.

[Me_2006 14]

I agree with Football Fan. Stay with what you have and play your matchups. Frye has been good this year when playing bad D's and Vick could get you 100 yds and a TD on the ground each week. You just arent getting enough in return for what you're giving up.

 

Thanks for the help on mine. Good luck.

[harrinjj22 0]

There is really now reason why you should do any. Unless you just want to trade, do #2.

[jgregory7 0]

I'd stand pat with what you have, but if you really wanna do a trade... i'd go with #2

[dbuofi7 0]

Hmm ... I agree with the others and stick with what you got. Option 2 does get you some depth at QB, but not sure that Droughns needs to be in there to get that one done. I would much rather have Droughns who at least is a starter rather than Pittman. That's the ideal situation.

 

Please see mine: http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=243030

 

Thanks in advance.

[ras_d 0]

I like your team with option #1. This doesnt look a stat heavy year for brady and pennington is suspect. Farve is going for it all... and vick tries to do it all.

 

option #2 is better in the WR dept. but how much, really?

[Bob Lee Swagger 0]

I like your team with #2 better.

 

Thanks for your reply.

[Moose42 0]

I would do #2. You shouldn't miss Droughns or Mason much. Getting Brady would be better off for the rest of the year.

 

 

please see mine http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=243086

[KSB2424 3,085]

I would stand pat. Thanks for mine.

[kcjoker 0]

if you feel you MUST take one or the either, take #2. the only thing you really get with the first in donald driver. i don't think you'll miss mason, and droughns won't be missed much either in the coming weeks. if i were you, i'd stay.

 

try mine?

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=243959