Should I make this trade?

[Beef Ravioli 0]

I trade Reggie Wayne and Selvin Young I get Steve Smith and Brandon Marshall.

 

I know there is concern at the moment about Steve Smith with Delhome out but Reggie has hurt me in the past when the Colts sit their starters after they clench and during my playoff run.

 

MY RB's andWR's

 

LT, SJax, MJD, B Jacobs, Selvin Young, M Turner

Reggie, Dwayne Bowe, Roddy White, Wes Welker

 

His RB's and WR's

 

Alexander, TJones, K Keith

Steve Smith, Roy Williams, Crayton, Brandon Marshall, McDonald, Cotchery

 

We can play two Rb's and two WR's or 1 Rb and 3 Wr - whichever we choose for that week.

 

Thanks and leave a link

[dpbuddha 9]

I really think the depth at WR will help you, Selvin Young is a throw-in at this point and while he will likely be the starter eventually you're so stacked at Rb that you don't have to worry about it. Are there no other teams out there that are hurting at RB? Seems like you should be able to get a very good WR without having to give up Wayne.

 

Please see mine

[ryan014 0]

I would do the deal....your WR depth is not pretty....Smith will get his sooner rather than later as soon as David Carr settles in (Andre Johnson got his with Carr at the helm) Young will be a starter but your RB's are solid....Marshall is an up and coming star and will get better every week!!!

[notJames 0]

I agree. Giving up a little in the RB dept. (which is already stacked) to shore up your WRs sounds like a good deal. Pull the trigger.

 

And thanks for answering my query.

[just_want_2_win 0]

I trade Reggie Wayne and Selvin Young I get Steve Smith and Brandon Marshall.

 

I know there is concern at the moment about Steve Smith with Delhome out but Reggie has hurt me in the past when the Colts sit their starters after they clench and during my playoff run.

 

MY RB's andWR's

 

LT, SJax, MJD, B Jacobs, Selvin Young, M Turner

Reggie, Dwayne Bowe, Roddy White, Wes Welker

 

His RB's and WR's

 

Alexander, TJones, K Keith

Steve Smith, Roy Williams, Crayton, Brandon Marshall, McDonald, Cotchery

 

We can play two Rb's and two WR's or 1 Rb and 3 Wr - whichever we choose for that week.

 

Thanks and leave a link

 

I'd do it. The Carolina QB situation is a mess but I think no matter what Smith gets the ball (even Carr managed to get it to him, barely) and his numbers will probably be comparable to Wayne. Young isn't anything at this point unless Henry's hurt as Henry's suspension probably won't go through for at least 5 weeks due to the system. Marshall will be a nice add.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=294605

[xxxravagexxx 0]

I'd do it. You need the WRs. Smith might see his production drop a bit, but hey who else are they gonna throw to. And the way Marshall's playing, he might end up with better number than Smith. Young's not even assured of starting when & if Henry gets suspended.

 

Here's mine.

[Mikenice81 1]

I trade Reggie Wayne and Selvin Young I get Steve Smith and Brandon Marshall.

 

I know there is concern at the moment about Steve Smith with Delhome out but Reggie has hurt me in the past when the Colts sit their starters after they clench and during my playoff run.

 

MY RB's andWR's

 

LT, SJax, MJD, B Jacobs, Selvin Young, M Turner

Reggie, Dwayne Bowe, Roddy White, Wes Welker

 

His RB's and WR's

 

Alexander, TJones, K Keith

Steve Smith, Roy Williams, Crayton, Brandon Marshall, McDonald, Cotchery

 

We can play two Rb's and two WR's or 1 Rb and 3 Wr - whichever we choose for that week.

 

Thanks and leave a link

 

Yes both players you are getting are better then what you are giving away

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=294617

[TX Steel 0]

Thanks for the help on mine.

 

Yeah I'd go for that deal. You've got the depth where you need it and these guys will be better than what you're giving up.