Big RB Trade

[brokenbricks 0]

Does this seem like a fair trade - 10 Team 2 QB, PPR league. 4pts QB TDs.

 

Player A gets - Ray Rice and Carson Palmer

 

Player B gets - Darren McFadden and Ryan Mathews (with Owen Daniels possibly thrown in)

 

What do you guys think. Owen Daniels could get thrown in if it would make it any more fair.

 

Thanks.

[TxTech9 5]

I'd like to be player A in this trade since its 2 QB. I'd like to know the rest of the teams though. Like who he's pairing ray rice with.

[brokenbricks 0]

I'd like to be player A in this trade since its 2 QB. I'd like to know the rest of the teams though. Like who he's pairing ray rice with.

Player A RB - Foster, Greene, Hillis, J Rodgers, K Hunter

QB - Matt Ryan, C Ponder

[FF Tracker 0]

Player A RB - Foster, Greene, Hillis, J Rodgers, K Hunter

QB - Matt Ryan, C Ponder

 

IMO that's too big a lost at RB.

 

I'd try and trade one of the back-ups for Palmer. Hillis?

[ziggyschiefs 0]

i think player B definitely gets a better deal. wouldnt need to throw in Daniels. Getting DMC AND Mathews is a powerful combo and only giving up Rice. Palmer is a backup but could give good numbers since it's 2 QB. But A is losing a lot of RB stock.

 

I agree with FF Tracker, go for just Palmer...

 

thanks for mine.

[dumbassmax2001 0]

It looks like player A will then roster both Foster & Rice and then get an upgrade at QB. Assuming you play only 2 RB's, I like player A's side of things regardless of the throw-in. At the same time, if player B is short on RB's, that's a pretty good deal for them also. Pretty fair all the way around from the looks of it.

 

Thanks for answering mine

[saut 7]

Love the possible Foster/Rice combo, although little depth if one of them should go down. Tough call but I think Player A wins this one.

[FF Tracker 0]

It looks like player A will then roster both Foster & Rice and then get an upgrade at QB. Assuming you play only 2 RB's, I like player A's side of things regardless of the throw-in. At the same time, if player B is short on RB's, that's a pretty good deal for them also. Pretty fair all the way around from the looks of it.

 

Thanks for answering mine

 

So you would rather have Foster and Rice over Foster, DMac, and Mathews?

 

I'd offer Hillis for Palmer.

[dumbassmax2001 0]

So you would rather have Foster and Rice over Foster, DMac, and Mathews?

 

I'd offer Hillis for Palmer.

 

Good point, I didn't look at it that way and you're right, I'd rather have Foster, DMac & Matthews even if Rice is > than the latter two.

[jackjohn 31]

Depending on how many rb's you start. If you start 2, I would rather have Foster and Rice. DMC & Mathews are a little too injury prone.

 

Good luck and thanks for mine!

[brokenbricks 0]

thanks for all the advice. the other owner wont bite. he wants carson palmer for mathews.