Top Five Redraft and Dynasty

[JimyKrackedKorn 0]

Hi. How would you rank just the top five for each? I'm lost after three. Portis seems the popular choice for four in both.

[Kitsnow 0]

IDP or not? scoring system?

[pacman_fl 0]

I've seen Portis as high as 3 in both, so I would say he is definitely 4 at worst for both. Redraft - Tiki is 4/5 (personal preference I suppose). Dynasty - who do you like? That's what it comes down to. S. Jackson, Ronnie Brown, Caddy, Jordan, Bush? Jordan for me based on PPR and he has proven he can handle the load with consistency (at least for 1 year), which the other haven't.

[JimyKrackedKorn 0]

IDP or not? scoring system?

 

I should know better by now, sorry.

 

One redraft-

 

1 QB

1 RB

2 WR

1 TE

2 Flex players (who must be a RB, WR, or TE)

1 K

1 Team Defense/Special team

 

 

Another redraft-

 

Scoring -

All TDs = 6pts.

1pt for 25yd pass

1pt for 10yd rush/rec.

1pt per reception

2pt for 2pt conversion (pass, run or catch)

-2 for interceptions thrown and fumbles lost

3pt for FG under 40 yards

4pt for FG 40-49 yards

5pt for 50yd and over

1pt for extra point

-1pt for missed extra point

 

 

Dynasty-

 

16 player rosters. No restrictions except that you must be able to fill your active roster.

 

Active roster – 1QB, 2RB, 2WR, 1TE, 1K, 1DEF,and 1 Flex (RB/WR/TE only)

 

Scoring -

All TDs = 6pts.

1pt for 25yd pass

1pt for 10yd rush/rec.

1pt per reception

2pt for 2pt conversion (pass, run or catch)

-2 for interceptions thrown and fumbles lost

3pt for FG under 40 yards

4pt for FG 40-49 yards

5pt for 50yd and over

1pt for extra point

-1pt for missed extra point

 

 

 

A lot to digest, but as requested. None are IDP

 

I've seen Portis as high as 3 in both, so I would say he is definitely 4 at worst for both. Redraft - Tiki is 4/5 (personal preference I suppose). Dynasty - who do you like? That's what it comes down to. S. Jackson, Ronnie Brown, Caddy, Jordan, Bush? Jordan for me based on PPR and he has proven he can handle the load with consistency (at least for 1 year), which the other haven't.

 

Who do I like? Jackson. Don't ask me why, but I've never liked Brown, Caddy or Jordan for the long haul.

[Raider 84 29]

Can't go wrong with Peyton. I like Brown or Portis.

[biggtyme13 0]

Can't go wrong with Peyton.

 

 

Have you ever did the valuations on Manning. I know position valuations are tuff to do in some leagues that dont have set positions like mine. But lets take a 12 team 2 rb league. The Valuation on Manning over the 12th qb will be like 130 The Valuation of a portis over the 24th running back will be like 220. by that youd gain 80 points thru the season by taking portis this works for most runningbacks and is my favorite method for determining position values thru the draft.

 

 

To aanswer the question Redraft 4-5 portis barber Dynasty 4-5 Ronnie Brown Cadilac Williams