Leinart, Young or Rivers

[OriginalMonkeyBoy 0]

details: 10 team, starting roster keeper (1QB, 2RB, 3WR, 1K, 1D)

 

I am looking at getting a QB for the future of my team this year. I think there is a good crop of QB's, with these three being the best.

 

Leinart - below average O-line, 2 elite WR's and stud RB. Missed training camp, but will probably be starting by midseason cuz of Warner's injuries

 

Young - I'm thinking he will be starting sooner, rather than later. Decent O-line, 1 decent WR and an unstable RB situation. More 'vick-like' than the other two.

 

Rivers - Most experience. Knows his players. below average WR's, but arguably the best RB/TE combo in the league. (a QB's best friend). decent O-line and a system where QB's can succeed.

 

I'm leaning towards making Rivers my pick, but the Fitz-Boldin-Edge combo really has me thinking. Will Leinart be another Leaf? Another Harrington? I'm looking for FF numbers, not superbowl rings.

 

Any thoughts? leave a link and I'll answer yours.

 

 

My current Keepers - Roethlisberger, Deuce, Portis, Moss, Horn, Harrison, Graham, Atlanta D

My picks this year - 1.1, 2.6, 2.9, 3.5, 3.9, 4.2, 5.2, 5.7 (8 round draft)

[OriginalMonkeyBoy 0]

bump

[c_Weezie 3]

Unless your in a 16 Team League I wouldnt even consider Leinart or Young. However I think Phillip Rivers would be a decent #2 QB in leagues w/ 12 or more teams.

[mobb_deep 917]

Unless your in a 16 Team League I wouldnt even consider Leinart or Young. However I think Phillip Rivers would be a decent #2 QB in leagues w/ 12 or more teams.

 

is this some sort of Dynasty League? It seems like some sort of hybrid keeper/dynasty league but I can't tell. I think all three of them have huge value in a Dynasty league. In a straight up keeper league I'd give the Edge to Rivers just because he's 2 years ahead of Young and Leinert even though none have started a regular season NFL game. Rivers also looked sharp in the pre-season game this last week.