Which of these auction teams is better?

[boogaloobboy 0]

200 dollar cap, start 1qb, 2rb, 2wr, 1te, 1 flex wr/rb/te, 1k, 1d. No ppr, 4 point pass TD.

Numbers by team are bye and salary paid.

Can keep 2 players a year (only 1 rb), salary increases 10%. Also must always have a rookie on the roster.

 

 

Team 1

 

QB Marc Bulger Rams (STL) 7 11

RB Clinton Portis Redskins (WAS) 8 41

RB Tiki Barber Giants (NYG) 4 51

WR Joey Galloway Buccaneers (TAM) 4 12

WR Darrell Jackson Seahawks (SEA) 5 20

TE Jerramy Stevens Seahawks (SEA) 5 2

R/W/T Brian Westbrook Eagles (PHI) 9 25

K Adam Vinatieri Colts (IND) 6 1

DEF Minnesota Vikings Vikings (MIN) 6 1

B-QB Matt Leinart Cardinals (ARI) 9 3

B-QB Ben Roethlisberger Steelers (PIT) 4 5

B-RB Mike Bell Broncos (DEN) 4 18

B-WR Michael Jenkins Falcons (ATL) 5 2

B-WR Corey Bradford Lions (DET) 8 1

B-WR Troy Williamson Vikings (MIN) 6 3

B-WR Hank Baskett Eagles (PHI) 9 3

B-TE Dallas Clark Colts (IND) 6 1

 

Remaining Salary Cap:$0 Total:$200

 

 

 

Team 2

 

QB Trent Green Chiefs (KC) 5 5

RB Shaun Alexander Seahawks (SEA) 5 72

RB Ronnie Brown Dolphins (MIA) 8 49

WR Larry Fitzgerald Cardinals (ARI) 9 33

WR Matt Jones Jaguars (JAC) 6 13

TE Leonard Pope Cardinals (ARI) 9 1

R/W/T Jerious Norwood Falcons (ATL) 5 4

K Neil Rackers Cardinals (ARI) 9 3

DEF Denver Broncos Broncos (DEN) 4 1

B-QB Jay Cutler Broncos (DEN) 4 1

B-RB Maurice Drew Jaguars (JAC) 6 1

B-RB Michael Turner Chargers (SDG) 3 3

B-QB Vince Young Titans (TEN) 4 2

B-WR Chris Henry Bengals (CIN) 5 2

B-WR Roddy White Falcons (ATL) 5 2

B-WR Chad Jackson Patriots (NWE) 6 2

B-WR Amani Toomer Giants (NYG) 4 1

 

Remaining Salary Cap:$8 Total:$192

[gobuckeyes 0]

Team 2's starters are ridiculously good especially in a league with only 4 points per pass td since the only beef on trent green is his annual poor performance in that catagory. However, the backups are really terrible, only starter is white and most of the rest arent even expected to start at any point. If someone goes down that team is in big trouble. For that reason only I would say team 1. However, if team 2 stays injury free they are much better than team 1.

 

With the number of carries SA got last year he can almost certainly be expected to miss a game or 2 and with the lack of any reasonable backup RB I think that will basicly cause team 2 to forfeit however many games he misses.

[sa37no1 0]

No doubt team 2...

[JediMaster 20]

Team 2

 

Please See Mine

[FBH ** 0]

In terms of the entire season, I would say that team one is the better all around team. There is no real substitute for depth in Fantasy Football.

 

Team 2 is better at RB1, RB2, and WR1, but team 1 is better everywhere else, and a much more stable team. If I had to choose one over the other for one week I would take team 2, but for an entire season I would take team 1. Just my .02.

 

Thanks for seeing mine.

[yomamahates 0]

Team 2: Shaun and Brown at RB will give them at least 60% of points. Honestly, I would choose Vinateri over Rackers any day. I think Rackers won't have a good season. The cardinals have backs and recievers and won't be settling for FG's. Team 2's Trent Green has been outstanding (4000+) compared to Bulger (still a good QB). Team 2 is dominate.

 

What sucks about Team 1 is getting Portis (probably first pick). Don't worry, it happened to me in another league I'm playing. I picked Portis 2 days before his injury. People said he'll be fine, but the team is looking for another RB already! If Portis was healthy it may be a toss up. Portis, Tiki, AND Westbrook starting would bring in major points. Yes...Shaun and Brown also bring in alot of points but I don't think the addition of Norwood would beat a healthy team 1 RB's. Then again Green will beat out Bulger this season.

 

Overall, Team 2 wins only because Portis is injured.

[nocarbs 0]

thanks for helping my link\

 

team 2 is a little more solid.

[STEELERMAN 0]

Team 2.....Better RB's & WR's w/ Fitzgerald!

Thanks for your response!

[weas98 0]

Team 2 and it's not even close...SA, Brown, Fitz, M Jones...nice auction skills

[sheadtoo 1]

In terms of the entire season, I would say that team one is the better all around team. There is no real substitute for depth in Fantasy Football.

 

Team 2 is better at RB1, RB2, and WR1, but team 1 is better everywhere else, and a much more stable team. If I had to choose one over the other for one week I would take team 2, but for an entire season I would take team 1. Just my .02.

[JREarly 0]

Team 2

 

 

thanks for your response

[PlasticElvis 0]

Yeah... team 2.