What do you think of this trade offer?

[TheShoe1010 1]

I recieve:

 

Plaxico Burress

Fred Taylor

 

He recieves:

 

Eddie Kennison

Deshaun Foster

 

MY roster is below...I already have Eli Manning...he already has Darrell Jackson/T.J. housh and DeAngelo Williams

 

Does this trade work out for both sides? Who gets the better deal?

[adanley 1]

Heck yeah. Foster will probably get hurt sometime anyway. Plaxico > Kennison.

 

Please see mine

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=228167

[leftyguitar 0]

the deal is a wash, nobody really benefits. same position players, same quality players... ehhh. and you won't like it when eli and plax go on bye the same week and you have to start two scrubs. Don't know why everyone's down on Kennison, he's had back to back 1000 yard seasons...

 

"Foster will probably get hurt sometime anyway." and Fred Taylor is less likely to????

 

 

please see my DEF and RB posts:

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=228107

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=228102

[mobb_deep 920]

I like it. I think the RB's are a wash even though Foster has more upside if he stays healthy (lets face it neither of the two are exactly men of steel). You're getting the much MUCH better WR out of the deal so I'd definitely pull the trigger. Good luck.

 

mine if you got a second

[scottlaroc 0]

Wow!

The G-men have a brutal, brutal schedule and we'll have to see if Eli is the guy that played the 1st half or the guy from the 2nd half of last season. So I'm not high on Plax.

F Taylor without G Jones should be fine. The fragile Fred monicker is overblown.

 

I actually really like E Kennison as an ok 2 or real solid 3 WR. I don't know how much DeShaun loses to DeAngelo but it could be enough.

 

So I agree with above it's a wash. But I think you'll make the deal cause I think you're a Giants fan???

[mrgymrat 0]

Plax for Kennison sounds good.

 

Hopefully you won't need to ever play Fragile Fred (but where Greg Jones is out then at least he will get carries when he's healthy).

 

Foster will get hurt or lose his job to DWilliams... IMO

 

It upgrades your WR position