To trade or not to trade

[seamus16 0]

Hey all I need a second opinion here.

I have Tom Brady and Mike Vick (Brady started this week)

I also have Steve Smith as my receiver and only Issac Bruce as any sort of decent compliment.

I have been offered a trade-- Vick For Drew Bennett, who had a big week.

What are your thoughts?

Thanks

[Rynoman 0]

I would if you have a large roster and a spot avaialble to drop someone and pickup a QB for Brady's bye week.

 

I mean Vick should never be used unless Tom gets hurt

 

I like Bennett a lot.

 

 

Mine

[throttlers 0]

Normally I would say no, because I think Vick will actually have a good year, and I think Bennett will be up and down all year. However, since yo uare hurting so much for a WR, I would consider it unless yo uhave other options to upgrade at WR.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=231939

[Melvinbet 5]

Do it. You have a reliable starting QB with Brady. You need Bennett more than you need Vick at this point.

[End3r 0]

I concur, even though Vick might have a good year, you have to stick with Brady so Vick will only be a bye week filler, and it seems like you need Bennett (who I think will have a solid year) more than you need Vick...

 

I say go for it...

[big blue bingo bob 0]

No. Vick would only be your back up

[HowieWan 0]

I hate Vick in fantasy because he is so up and down, so I would get rid of him and take Bennett. Brady should be your starter every week except the bye. If the other guy really wants Vick and he has a WR you like better than Bennett, make a counter-offer for another WR. I happen to think the trade is pretty good for you, although you cannot expect WR1 numbers from Bennett every week. As long as your expectations are tempered, make the trade.