hagler 0 Posted September 23, 2006 Also, I get Reggie Williams or Troy Williamson..... I give up: Plummer McGahee Droughns ---tough sched L.White I Receive: Vick J.Jones ---- Is he OK w/o having Barber A.Green/Herron Reggie Williams or Troy Williamson My Questions: Do I do this deal? Do I take Vick or Culpepper (I'm getting a choice) Do I take R.Williams or Troy Williamson? (I also have a choice here) Leaves me with the following RBs: Portis/Betts J.Jones/A.Green/Herron Please help! Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
pimptastic69 0 Posted September 23, 2006 I'd take this deal. Definately take Vick, and prolly take Williamson. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
vinniedasquid 0 Posted September 23, 2006 Also, I get Reggie Williams or Troy Williamson..... I give up: Plummer McGahee Droughns ---tough sched L.White I Receive: Vick J.Jones ---- Is he OK w/o having Barber A.Green/Herron Reggie Williams or Troy Williamson My Questions: Do I do this deal? Do I take Vick or Culpepper (I'm getting a choice) Do I take R.Williams or Troy Williamson? (I also have a choice here) Leaves me with the following RBs: Portis/Betts J.Jones/A.Green/Herron Please help! Looks to me like it'd be an upgrade at the 3 main positions for you. I'd definitely take Vick over Cpep, Vick's put up some ff pts against a couple better-than-they-appear defenses in Carolina and Tampa. I like Williamson because although Williams had a great game last week, I still don't see him emerging as the #1 threat in Jax; Williamson should definitely be more consistent. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
jaguiar88 3 Posted September 23, 2006 I would take Vick and do the deal Please help me http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=236643 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
baltfool 0 Posted September 23, 2006 Would Vick (for sure take him over C-Pep) start for you or do you have a starting QB? I'd probably take Williams over Williamson if I was doing the trade, but it's a toss-up. Overall, if Vivk isn't going to be your starter or isn't an upgrade for you over your starter, I am not sure i would do it. McGehee is the most solid player (at the most solid position) going in this trade. Green/Herron may be an upgrade, but what if Green is hurt or get's hurt and Morency starts, then you got jack. J.Jones is decent for sure, but always an injury risk/risk of losing carries. L.White is better RB depth than eanything you are getting in return. It's close if Vick is going to be your starter (and who knows, Plummer could bounce back), otherwise, don't do it. On second thought, just don't do it. Hang on another week to see what happens with White, Plummer, Droughns..... Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
