should i trade shaun alexander, now?

[The Hunter 0]

standard scoring, twelve team league. i'm behind the eight ball, having lost a bunch in a row.

 

qb - c. pennington, j.p. losman

rb - c. taylor, k. jones, s.alexander, m.morris, w.lundy, j.norwood

wr - m.harrison, t.j.houshmandzadeh, j.galloway, e.parker (put a bid on romo to replace him)

te - l.j. smith

k - s.graham

def - ny giants

 

his team

qb - m. bulger, b.roethlisberger

rb - w.dunn, r.droughns, l.jordan, m.moore, m.anderson, j.fargas

wr - l.fitzgerald, r.brown, b.berrian, k.johnson, d.gabriel

te - a.smith

k - j.feely

def - denver broncos

 

he's offered me marc bulger and warrick dunn for shaun alexander. am i crazy for even considering that? should i ask for more? any responses would be helpful.

[jbogli 0]

I would take this trade. You can get a great qb in bulger which you need badly and also get a decent RB. You could then look to shop dunn. I am not sold on Romo yet though he managed the offense well. SA didn't look good before he got hurt and hasslebeck will be out a couple more too. I think chester and KJ are good enough to get you bye with Bulger. I think this trade allows you to score more points consistently.

[dparsons02 0]

I agree that youd should take this trade. Who knows how long SA will be healthy once he comes back (I dont care what anyone says the madden curse is for real). You are getting a solid QB and a decent RB. Also Dunnmay pick it up as it looks like the Atlanta offence is entering uncharted territory with Vick...dare I say it...sitting in the pocket.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=249294

[bauman88 0]

Very intriguing question.

 

I would keep Alexander. It looks like wallace will be OK at QB and they really need a winning streak. Holmgren knows how to ride his horse.

 

see me

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=249308

[The Hunter 0]

i've also been offered:

reggie wayne, straight up, for shaun alexander

marion barber, santana moss and chad johnson for shaun alexander

 

are either of those better than

 

marc bulger, warrick dunn, and potentially a throw-in for shaun alexander?

[DandyRandy 0]

I would take the M.Barber S.Moss and C.Johnson trade.

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=249366

[Larry David 20]

I wouldn't do it. I think that Pennington and Alexander will outscore Bulger and Dunn the rest of the way.

 

See mine... http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=249310

[A Dido Brother 0]

You could use a weekly starter stud at QB, and Bulger's the man. Honestly, I'm starting to think SA's not going to come back with a vengeance, seeing how long it's taking to heal up. You've got a pretty stacked RB corps as it is.

[Beyond Chaos 75]

I'd take the trade. Bulger and Dunn seem fair enough, SA won't be back til at least week 10....

 

You can trade Dunn if you have to.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=249374

[dalie 2]

I would take the Bulger/Dunn trade. You get a much better QB and Dunn should hold his own.

 

MBIII/SMoss/CJ doesn't help you as much (depending on the # or WR's you start) because you have 2 Quality WR's already

 

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=249279