List of Keepers

[Kelvarr 13]

These were the core of my team last year. I guess you could throw McNabb in there also, but I've soured on him a bit because of the injury, and no WR in Philly.

 

I was thinking about Vick (Put up top 5 numbers in our league last year), but with the whole dog thing going on.

 

I know Bush is a popular keeper also, but then I look at Ronnie Brown and I scratch my head.

 

KEEP ONE.

 

Thanks.

[WoodDuck2003 0]

I really think it depends on a lot. Do you give up a draft pick? If so which round?

 

I am going to assume everyone has to keep 1 player and no rounds given up. In this case I think you have to go with the player who will produce the most points and has the least amount of risk. That player is R.Brown.

 

Thanks for seeing mine.

[Kelvarr 13]

I really think it depends on a lot. Do you give up a draft pick? If so which round?

 

I am going to assume everyone has to keep 1 player and no rounds given up.

 

You are correct, sir!

 

Thanks.

[Stewburtx8 67]

If everyone keeps one guy and then you draft from there, my answer all depends on whether this is a PPR league or not. If it's a PPR league then I'd definitely keep Bush. Bush could get 90 catches this year, which should be 30-40 more than Ronnie Brown, who does catch pretty many himself. Bush is soo verstatile in that offense and I think he gets double digit TD's in a variety ways, that should be equal or more than Brown. I think the 30-40 more points from catches easily make up in the difference in rushing+receiving yards between the two. If it's not a PPR league then I lean towards Brown, but still might keep Bush because of his better long term value and slight downgrade, if any, this year.

[Kelvarr 13]

No PPR (if PPR is Point Per Reception). 1 pt/5yds rush, 6 pts/TD, 1 pt/5yds rec.

[bjlmonster 0]

Ronnie Brown!

[Kelvarr 13]

So Vick is definitely out...it seems the consensus (from reading other sources) is either Bush or Brown. People here say Brown. Is Brown that much better than Bush?

[Stewburtx8 67]

So Vick is definitely out...it seems the consensus (from reading other sources) is either Bush or Brown. People here say Brown. Is Brown that much better than Bush?

 

 

No he's not. I could see Brown with about 1600 total yards and 9 TD's and Reggie Bush with about 1500 total yards and 11 TD's. So using your scoring system Brown outscores him by a couple points. BUT Reggie Bush is younger and has a ton more upside, not only for this year, but for the future. I think you'd be foolish to let a long term keeper like Bush go for a guy thats MAYBE slightly better this year and not a top 10 back kind of guy this year either.