jimwomer 0 Posted October 11, 2007 I got offered Larry Johnson/Bennett and Calvin Johnson for Rudi/Watson and Steve Smith. Is this a good trade for me? So far Rudi/Smith have outscored Johnson/Johnson, but I am worried about Rudi's hammy and David Carr throwing to Smith. On the other hand LJ hasn't done much and Calvin Johnson has had back problems. I am in a 16 team redraft league where I can either start 1 RB/4 receivers or 2 RB/3 receivers My roster is: QB Vince Young RB Rudi Johnson, Kenny Watson, Kevin Jones, LenDale White, Warrick Dunn, Jerious Norwood WR/TE Steve Smith, L. Coles, Brandon Marshall, Ronald Curry, Kellen Winslow K Crosby D Baltimore What do you think? Leave a link for yours Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
mrgymrat 0 Posted October 11, 2007 I would so steer clear of LJ & the Chefs (not a typo). Stick w/ Rudi & Smith. If you were stuck with your LJ as your wasted 1st round pick, you'd be doing the same offer. PEOPLE who rushed for more yds than LJ last week: (Brian Moorman the punter from the Bills almost had as much as LJ in 1 carry) 1. Michael Turner 147 2. Kenton Keith 121 3. Ronnie Brown 114 4. Brian Leonard 102 5. Sammy Morris 102 6. Willie Parker 102 7. Brandon Jacobs 100 8. Edgerrin James 88 9. Willis McGahee 88 10. Maurice Jones-Drew 82 11. DeShawn Wynn 78 12. Clinton Portis 72 13. Reggie Bush 67 14. LaDainian Tomlinson 67 15. Marshawn Lynch 66 16. Travis Henry 65 17. Cedric Benson 64 18. DeShaun Foster 59 19. Jason Wright 59 20. Najeh Davenport 58 21. Derrick Ward 56 22. Frank Gore 52 23. Fred Taylor 51 24. Artose Pinner 49 (1 carry) 25. Kevin Jones 48 26. Vernand Morency 43 27. Julius Jones 41 28. Ron Dayne 40 29. Thomas Jones 36 30. LenDale White 32 31. Marion Barber 28 32. Chris Brown 27 33. Warrick Dunn 27 34. Vince Young 27 35. Shaun Alexander 25 36. Clifton Dawson 24 (who?) 37. Mike Sellers 24 38. Trent Green 23 39. Jerious Norwood 23 40. DeAngelo Williams 23 41. Ladell Betts 22 42. Sam Gado 19 43. Eli Manning 17 44. Kyle Eckel 16 (who?) 45. Tatum Bell 15 46. Reuben Droughns 47. Chris Davis 14 (who?) 48. Greg Jones 14 49. Leon Washington 13 50. Larry Johnson 12 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
MikeyNavy 1 Posted October 11, 2007 Stay where you are. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
eagles114 0 Posted October 11, 2007 Ya I wouldnt give up that much for larry. I just traded Peterson and Kitna for Larry and Jacobs. Why did I do that trade you may ask? I also have reggie and Rudi. Not feeling very confident with Rudi and his injury. And Bush is being used as trade bait for a number 1 wideout Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
squirly 0 Posted October 11, 2007 I got offered Larry Johnson/Bennett and Calvin Johnson for Rudi/Watson and Steve Smith. Is this a good trade for me? So far Rudi/Smith have outscored Johnson/Johnson, but I am worried about Rudi's hammy and David Carr throwing to Smith. On the other hand LJ hasn't done much and Calvin Johnson has had back problems. I am in a 16 team redraft league where I can either start 1 RB/4 receivers or 2 RB/3 receivers My roster is: QB Vince Young RB Rudi Johnson, Kenny Watson, Kevin Jones, LenDale White, Warrick Dunn, Jerious Norwood WR/TE Steve Smith, L. Coles, Brandon Marshall, Ronald Curry, Kellen Winslow K Crosby D Baltimore What do you think? Leave a link for yours i dont think i would do it. i have lj, he has been horrible but am hoping he comes around with easier schedule Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
BLT 0 Posted October 11, 2007 LJs schedule gets easier the next 4-5 weeks.FYI Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
pimptastic69 0 Posted October 11, 2007 I would so steer clear of LJ & the Chefs (not a typo). Stick w/ Rudi & Smith. If you were stuck with your LJ as your wasted 1st round pick, you'd be doing the same offer. PEOPLE who rushed for more yds than LJ last week: (Brian Moorman the punter from the Bills almost had as much as LJ in 1 carry) Rudi Johnson: 58 rushes for 177 yards = 3.1 ypc 2 fumbles lost Larry Johnson: 84 rushes for 275 yards = 3.3 ypc 0 fumbles lost What makes Rudi so much better than LJ? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
eagles114 0 Posted October 11, 2007 Guys if we are fortunate to make it to the playoffs!! Larry goes against the LIONS AND JETS!!! Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
eagles114 0 Posted October 11, 2007 You really cant blame Larry. I watched that game JAX dominated the game from start to finish! Didnt Jax have like 40 mins of possession? I am not worried about his perfomance. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
