Need an honest opinion

[Pa_boda 0]

I play in a 2 QB league and Farve is my no. 1 and has done very well. I have Vince Young and Alex Smith as choices for no. 2. I am considering picking up Losman off waivers and dropping either Young or Smith. Who should I drop? I'm in a keeper league and QB score tons of points so having 2 decent QB's is a great advantage. I would like to get opinions about the long term (this season and beyond) potential of these guys. I'm in first place right now but no thanks to my second QB! Thanks for the help and I'll answer yours

[beatsdesign 0]

Tuff one....without the keepers its definately throw vince away time but i like him longterm more than alex smith. at the end of the year i would rather have alex and vince than losman. but youre in first so dump smith or stay put.

 

JB

 

thanks for mine

[mrgymrat 0]

Those 3 are all a crapshoot... no one else? I would look elsewhere.

[Pa_boda 0]

The other options are Lemmons, McNown and Tavaris Jackson. Are they a better option?

[chuck_w87 0]

The other options are Lemmons, McNown and Tavaris Jackson. Are they a better option?

 

I would honestly pick up McCown because he plays the Texans. Losman is Losman... and will always be Losman. With him you can only pray for the long bomb to Evans. McCown has put up big numbers before. Unless you are talking about Cade McNown... then you can look elsewhere.

[Leshavelli 0]

Dump Smith and pick-up Losman. He is determined to keep his job and plays a skanky Bengals D this week. Even if the Bengals offense unloads on Buffalo, JP will still have to rely on the pass to catch up. Not to mention, JP has a favorable schedule down the stretch. He and Lee Evans really turned it on down the stretch last year. Smith has nothing around him and Gore can't get it going with a shady O-Line.

 

Mine -----> http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=299739

[drmidd 2]

For this week Id take Losman for sure and Id drop Alex. Being that it is a keeper league, I sure wouldnt want to let Vince go

 

See mine

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=299740

[bretthski 0]

Dump Vinny - when was the last time he threw for a TD? week 3? Titans will run the ball, not throw it. Any other options out there besides Losman?

 

Thanks for helping w/mine.

[Pa_boda 0]

Ok..it is down to taking Mcnown or Losman and dropping Smith or Vinny........If a QB does good in a particular week he gets scooped up pretty fast in our league so there usually isn't much talent on the waiver wires (which is obvious). Because it is a keeper league I'm concerned about more than one week so who has the most long term potential?

[Guest ramrock11]

JP