Make the trade?

[j0ker 3]

I was offered Breaston for Tomlinson. Granted this is not some blockbuster deal and frankly not even sure why the guy wants Tomlinson that bad. He did lose Ryan Grant but I think he has adequate replacements equivalent to Tomlinson. I'm prob going to turn it down unless you guys tell me to do otherwise. I see Tomlinson having a decent year later on if Greene continues to look bad. For the record here are the lineups (just rb's and wr's) Thanks and leave a link

 

 

Mine

 

Jones Drew, Foster, Harrison, Tomlinson, Jennings

 

DJax, Austin, Nenne, Knox

 

 

His

 

Chris Johnson, Mendenhall, Ryan Grant, Fred Jackson, Ricky Williams, Thomas Jones

 

Brandon Marshall, Smith (carolina), Breaston, Sims Walker

[Axe Elf 0]

"Nenne" LOL

 

Yeah, you don't really need Tomlinson, but Breaston doesn't help you much either, and you'll be able to get more for Tomlinson in the near future.

 

Tomlinson and Naanee for Steve Smith and Ricky Williams, maybe...

[andaval 0]

If you start 3 WR, Breaston might upgrade your starting lineup. See how the games go this weekend, and see if Breaston looks to be a real upgrade to Nanee?

[phorts 0]

Your WR Depth is much better than your RB Depth. I wouldnt trade LT, and certainly not for Breaston. Even if i thought it was an equal deal i wouldnt do it if i were you since it doesnt fit your needs.

 

Good luck and thanks for the help w/ mine

[Lake209 46]

I like both Tomlinson and Breaston. Greene looked pretty terrible...he closed his eyes on that fumble...closed his eyes??!!...not a good sign. I like LT going forward in NY; barring injury, he'll have great start or trade value for you in the future. The trade itself (right now) isn't a bad one. Breaston looks great, w/no Boldin. But you appear ok at WR for now... I stash the quality RB for later.