Which side of this trade would you want to be on?

[NPNG 4]

Side 1 gets A. Luck/M. Gordon/S. Perine

 

Side 2 gets C. Wentz/K. Hunt/M. Bryant

[Blkmcoupe 2]

Gordon and Perine

 

QBs are a wash. Gordon will be a beast this year (my opinion obviously). Hunt is a rookie and is totally unknown. He could end up being a Marvin Gordon (crap rookie season). You just don't know. Perine, according to "the experts", will be taking over the backfield in Washington by mid-season. Bryan is sharing touches with AB and Bell. I wouldn't draft him in the 3rd round like so many people have.

 

Statistically Gordon is going in the 1st round (8 overall). Hunt is going in the mid 2nd and Bryan in the mid 3rd. Wentz, Perine, and Luck are going super late. So, would you trade a 2nd and a 3rd round for a 1st round? It's certainly tempting especially if you believe in those round values. I view Hunt more as a 3rd rounder and Bryant more like a 5th rounder so I'd keep Gordon. If I was giving up Gordon I'd want a better WR with Hunt.

 

Another part of the puzzle is knowing how you're plugging the holes. For example, in my trade dilemma (link below) trading Hyde for Michael Thomas seems like a no brainer but it leaves me short at RB, depending on how long Zek is out. Even if Zek plays the whole season, do you go with Zek and Gurley the whole season without a strong 3rd RB in case one of them gets hurt? It's a tough decision (at least for me) because it leaves me vulnerable at RB.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=468868

[weepaws 2,460]

I'll take side two.

[montana 89]

#2