Keep Kittle for a 9th or Mayfield for a 14th?

[SabreNation 3]

This is a 12-team 1/2 PPR league - all other scoring rules are pretty standard. 

 

We're allowed to keep one player if desired with the following rules: 

• Drafted in the 9th round or later
• They were on your team the whole year
• You forfeit your current year pick 2 rounds earlier

We are only allowed to keep one player though so I have a decision to make since I drafted George Kittle in the 11th and Baker Mayfield in the 16th round. If it was perfectly even I'd take Kittle every time but there's a five round difference in the pick I have to give up so I'm a little torn. 

It may also be worth mentioning that both Pat Mahomes and Jared Goff will DEFINITELY be keepers for their respective teams in this league. 

[weepaws 2,461]

Kittle

[jimaveli 119]

Kittle. It’s not close.