Which trade would you take

[IndyFan 2]

Which deal (if any) would you take and why? We keep three players.

 

 

1) I give Calvin Johnson, Cedric Benson and an 8th for Colston, McFadden and a 4th

 

2) I give Calvin Johnson, Cedric Benson and an 8th for R White, McFadden and a 4th

 

3) Pass on both deals

[bluesrams2 0]

Well I prefer White over Colston.. So #2. But only if you're weak at RB. What's the rest of your team?

[IndyFan 2]

Rest of team is

 

Warner

Schaub

 

K Smith

J Jones

Benson

LT

Moreno

 

Ocho

Edwards

S Smith

C Johnson

S Moss

 

Z Miller

 

Tynes

 

Washington

Philly

[rippermd 0]

I would pass I think you dont do much to change your current team and risk vs benefit not that great

[bluesrams2 0]

If you have the option to start just 2 WR I would go for #2. Start weekly LT (if he doesn't have the down year everyone is predicting) Smith, and DMC at flex with Ocho and White at WR. Moreno should pick up the slack in a few weeks and he could be a starter if LT busts.

 

It's a bit trickier if you have to start 3 WRs. Edwards worries me. If you're high on him though go for it.

[BigMilk 40]

I like White over Colston, and you could use a little help at RB. But if you have to decide right now, I'd pass. You're team is solid and the upside for you is not that great. I'd sit tight for now.

[webbah 0]

Thanks for answering mine - I would go with your choice number 3 but if you really wanted to deal - then go with White over Colston.

[dpbuddha 9]

I would definitely stick with what you've got. Your team looks good, don't mess with it at this point.

 

Thanks for getting mine earlier.

[HTH 95]

I wouldn't trade megatron.

 

So c.

 

Thanks for answering mine.