Should I Try to Trade for McGahee?

[just_want_2_win 0]

My roster:

 

QB: Bulger, Kitna (start 1)

RB: Tiki, Foster, M. Jones-Drew, Barber III, Lundy (2)

WR: Boldin, Colston, Evans (2)

TE: Des. Clark, McMichael (1)

K: Andersen

D/ST: Seahawks (for this week's match up then plan to pick up someone else)

 

Should I try to get McGahee to be my #2? He's been disappointing this year -- only 1 TD and in my league 70 pts. to 68 for DeShaun Foster, my main #2 for the most of year. (Original backs after draft were Tiki, Foster, Jordan, Barber III). But McGahee's remaining schedule is favorable and Foster's been disappointing and has DeAngelo Williams coming back. Or should I stick with a #2 RBBC and rotate according to match ups? I know MJD has a nice schedule coming up and with Fred Taylor so fragile (though not this year) could be the man in JAX at any time.

 

If I try for McGahee, who should I package? Here's the other owner's team:

 

McNabb, Huard

McGahee, Taylor, Bush, Jordan

Andre Johnson, Wayne, Branch

Heap, Dal. Clark

Longwell

Raiders, Vikings

 

Foster and MJD perhaps, since MJD could handcuff Taylor?

[DandyRandy 0]

Get McGahee. for Foster will be replaced by DeAngelo Williams next week or the week afterGo straight up.If you have to package anyone it sould be Lundy.

see mine

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=250631

[J.E.T.S.JetsJetsJets 0]

Foster and MJD perhaps, since MJD could handcuff Taylor?

 

that's your best bet, I'd do it ASAP (maybe Sun night) so that he won't be picking up a dead bench spot which will make him more marketable.

 

I'm with you on DFoster on the wane, and that is also the prevailing notion which probably makes a 2 for 1 necessary. You may have to throw in Kitna since Huard likely has another pair of starts... definately open the dialogue as you suggested though.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=250656

[sb2232 0]

If you can swing a deal to get McGahee, do it. His schedule is very favorable down the stretch. What you have to give up makes it a little tougher. If you can get him for Foster and MJD, I say DO IT!

 

Help appreciated:

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=250638

[ramblin'wreck 0]

I would prefer McGahee over Foster anyday .. you can try Foster for McGahee straight up, if the other guy wouldn't do it, then you sweeten the deal by adding Jones-Drew.

 

 

 

Help me here..

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=250663

[rottytiny 7]

I'd try to get McGahee but I can't see the other owner giving him up, his RB's are not real tough. If I was the other owner something like Foster and Jones-Drew for McGahee and ???

 

Throw some offers at him and see what happens. Good Luck.

[nos23 1]

i would get willis any of those deals would work. thanks

[king41 0]

I'd try to get McGahee but I can't see the other owner giving him up, his RB's are not real tough. If I was the other owner something like Foster and Jones-Drew for McGahee and ???

 

Throw some offers at him and see what happens. Good Luck.

 

Thanks for mine...Agreed w/above

[Ricky's Swami 0]

My roster:

 

QB: Bulger, Kitna (start 1)

RB: Tiki, Foster, M. Jones-Drew, Barber III, Lundy (2)

WR: Boldin, Colston, Evans (2)

TE: Des. Clark, McMichael (1)

K: Andersen

D/ST: Seahawks (for this week's match up then plan to pick up someone else)

 

Should I try to get McGahee to be my #2? He's been disappointing this year -- only 1 TD and in my league 70 pts. to 68 for DeShaun Foster, my main #2 for the most of year. (Original backs after draft were Tiki, Foster, Jordan, Barber III). But McGahee's remaining schedule is favorable and Foster's been disappointing and has DeAngelo Williams coming back. Or should I stick with a #2 RBBC and rotate according to match ups? I know MJD has a nice schedule coming up and with Fred Taylor so fragile (though not this year) could be the man in JAX at any time.

 

If I try for McGahee, who should I package? Here's the other owner's team:

 

McNabb, Huard

McGahee, Taylor, Bush, Jordan

Andre Johnson, Wayne, Branch

Heap, Dal. Clark

Longwell

Raiders, Vikings

 

Foster and MJD perhaps, since MJD could handcuff Taylor?

 

 

If you have to pay anything more than Foster + Lundy to get McGahee than I would just stay put. Make a low ball offer for McGahee and then go as high as Foster + Lundy but don't give up MJD and Foster for a guy who's value isn't much better than Foster alone. Just b/c DeAngelo is getting healthy doesn't mean Foster's season is over.

[PythonPatrol 0]

Thanks for mine...Agreed w/above

I second that!! Good luck this week.

[dhartin 0]

tell u waht i would try, he has mcnaab on bye... kitna has high numbers, and is could be replaced for mcown as a change of pace.......

 

try.... deshaun, kitna, evans....... for mcgahee and andre.... something of that nature.... colston and andre is a nice 1 -2 ... especially in yahoo where u can put colston at TE..... if he doesnt bite that, i would do the MJD, and deshaun for mcgahee, willis has an easy schedule down the stretch and will be a hott comodity when people start to realize.....

 

i am not john clayton, but willis is a touch better than deshaun

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=250689