*** clash's draft discussion thread ***

[JoeBoxers43 0]

Tier I

 

myjimmy

worm

 

 

Tier II

 

Hardball

Yippie

FeelingMN

SMath

Clash

Sweetness

pauld

 

Tier III

 

JoeBoxer

mzf5c5

MTSki

 

i would love to know how u feel im in the bottom tier

 

top 5 qb, 2 top 10 rbs, wrs ye kinda shaky, but i messed up with the branch pick...and u cant judge my team now based on what happened with benson...TE nothing special, and best scoring defense...i mean ye after my branch and benson picks i guess u could rank me in the bottom 3, but being a giants fan and knowing jacobs cant cut it a full 16 games, i could possibly have the best rbs in the league...other than that ur right, my team nothing special...based on potential though, if smitty becomes who he was with delhomme, and santonio grows a bit with bigben, i think i can contend with my rbs

[FeelingMN 273]

i would love to know how u feel im in the bottom tier

 

top 5 qb, 2 top 10 rbs, wrs ye kinda shaky, but i messed up with the branch pick...and u cant judge my team now based on what happened with benson...TE nothing special, and best scoring defense...i mean ye after my branch and benson picks i guess u could rank me in the bottom 3, but being a giants fan and knowing jacobs cant cut it a full 16 games, i could possibly have the best rbs in the league...other than that ur right, my team nothing special...based on potential though, if smitty becomes who he was with delhomme, and santonio grows a bit with bigben, i think i can contend with my rbs

 

Roethlisberger is not a top 5 QB. He wasn't last year (8) and I expect to see fewer TDs this year. He's still a good QB....but not top 5. You're right to say your RBs are impressive. AD and Grant will score a lot of points this year. I also like SS this year. He won't put up monster stats like a few years ago, but he could return to top 10 status. I don't see Holmes expanding that much on last year's numbers. Gage and Johnson could become serviceable, but then again they could disappear too. Johnson had opportunity to shine last year in a better passing game than SF and didn't. I'm not expecting much from him.

 

After the first 5 or 6 rounds I thought you had one of the better teams, but the Branch and Benson picks might be comlpetely useless. In no way do I think you have a bad team. If this was a team you drafted it would be competitive if you played the wire right. But completely wiffing on your WR3 and RB3 during the draft has to hurt.

[JoeBoxers43 0]

Roethlisberger is not a top 5 QB. He wasn't last year (8) and I expect to see fewer TDs this year. He's still a good QB....but not top 5. You're right to say your RBs are impressive. AD and Grant will score a lot of points this year. I also like SS this year. He won't put up monster stats like a few years ago, but he could return to top 10 status. I don't see Holmes expanding that much on last year's numbers. Gage and Johnson could become serviceable, but then again they could disappear too. Johnson had opportunity to shine last year in a better passing game than SF and didn't. I'm not expecting much from him.

 

After the first 5 or 6 rounds I thought you had one of the better teams, but the Branch and Benson picks might be comlpetely useless. In no way do I think you have a bad team. If this was a team you drafted it would be competitive if you played the wire right. But completely wiffing on your WR3 and RB3 during the draft has to hurt.

 

 

no complaints there, benson noone knew about at the time so i really cant be held wrongly for that..branch was my fault bc of lack on preparation...gage i dont expect much from, bryant a little, but nonetheless you r correct

[myjimmy1 0]

Joeboxer --L.Betts was already off the board Mtskibum took him earlier as a courtesy i will wait a couple of hours to take my picks hope you see this

[myjimmy1 0]

joe go ahead and take your pick

[myjimmy1 0]

Sorry Joe didn't want to hold up the end of the draft go ahead and make your pick anytime

[JoeBoxers43 0]

sorry for the delay guys, no worries, entering both my picks now

[FeelingMN 273]

myjimmy

QB: Brees, V. Young

RB: LT, F. Taylor, Chester Taylor, SA

WR: Braylon E, Greg Jennings, Chambers, Curtis, Hardy

TE: Tony Gonzalez, Watson

K: Folk

DEF: Dallas

 

JoeBoxer

QB: Big Ben, Kitna

RB: ADP, Ryan Grant, Benson, A. Bradshaw, Foster

WR: Steve Smith, S. Holmes, D. Branch, Gage, Bryant Johnson

TE: Heath Miller

K: Graham

DST: San Diego

 

worm

QB: McNabb, Delhomme

RB: Westy, MJD, B. Jacobs, Deuce, Leon Washington

WR: Colston, Roy Williams, Driver, Bruce, Curry

TE: O. Daniels

K: Crosby

DEF: Seattle

 

mzf5c5

QB: Brady, Russell

RB: J. Lewis, Edge, A. Green, Felix Jones, K. Watson

WR: TJ Housh, Ward, Mason, Toomer, Wilford

TE: Dallas Clark

K: Bironas

DEF: Indy

 

Yippie

QB: Hasselbeck, A. Smith

RB: Steven Jackson, Reggie Bush, Forte, Chris Johnson, Ricky Williams

WR: Welker, Bowe, Berrian, Gaffney

TE: Gates, Crumpler

K: Dawson

DEF: Jax

 

Hardball

QB: Romo, Schaub

RB: Addai, Maroney, Mendenhall, Perry

WR: B.Marshall, Calvin Johnson, V. Jackson, R. Meacham, Hester, Sweed

TE: Cooley

K: Vinatieri

DST: Minnesota

 

Clash

QB: P.Manning, T. Edwards

RB: Gore,Turner, Kevin Smith, Norwood, Dunn

WR: Holt, L. Coles, J. Walker, Reggie Brown, Reggie Williams

TE: Kellen Winslow II

K: Rackers

DEF: New England

 

Feeling MN

QB: Bulger, Garrard

RB: Portis, R.Brown, T.Jones, S Young, Sammy Morris

WR: Fitz, Plaxico, S. Moss, A. Gonzalez, Booker

TE: V. Davis

K: Gould

DEF: Baltimore

 

Sweetness_34

QB: P Rivers, A. Rodgers

RB: M.Lynch, D. McFadden, Rudi, J.Stewart

WR: A. Johnson, Ocho Cinco, Engram, K. Walter, Ginn Jr.

TE: Shockey, G. Olsen

DEF: Bears

 

MTSkiBum

QB: Cutler, Leinart

RB: MBIII, E.Graham, L.White, L. Betts, Hightower

WR: Wayne, Boldin, Cotchery, S. Rice, Burleson, Mark Clayton

TE: Scheffler

 

pauld

QB: C. Palmer

RB: L. Johnson, W. McGahee, D. Williams, C. Brown, R. Rice

WR: Lee Evans, R.White, Galloway, J Porter, D Stallworth, Hackett

TE: Witten

DEF: Philly

 

SMath

QB: D. Anderson, E Manning

RB: FWP, Julius Jones, Henry, Fargas, Torain

WR: R.Moss, TO, Harrison, P Crayton

TE: Heap

K: Gostkowski

DEF: Pittsburgh

[myjimmy1 0]

After the draft if you have time everyone should rate who they think the top 5 teams are and just for fun the bottom 2 ---good draft by everyone and was fun except for the delays

[myjimmy1 0]

With the draft down to its last few picks guess i will lead off with who i like and dislike (even though i thought all the teams drafted decently

 

Top 5 (No Specific Order)

 

Worm-----Good all around team ---needs QB's to stay healthy

Myjimmy1----My team another good all around team needs one of his RB's to have solid #2 year

Hardball----Good Starting team needs to stay healthy --no bench

Feelin Minn---Qb'ing could be troublesome and needs a healthy R.Brown

Sweetness 34---like the Rodgers pick as backup Rivers should be healthy good starting wides no backups though

 

 

 

Bottom 2 (not bad teams but someone has to be lower tier)

 

Mzf5c5---old at RB, great starting QB, no bench

Yippie Skippy---love Jackson weak at Wr after Welker

 

*note*

MtSkiBum----going to be short either a k or a def

 

 

overall good job by all and only took about a month LOL

[MTSkiBum 1,605]

*note*

MtSkiBum----going to be short either a k or a def

 

Going to be short both a kicker and a defense.

 

And i will make my 15th round pick here in about an hour.

[myjimmy1 0]

Looks like this thing is dead with 2 picks to go, had a good time participating even though at times slowed to a crawl thanks everybody

[MTSkiBum 1,605]

myjimmy

QB: Brees, V. Young

RB: LT, F. Taylor, Chester Taylor, SA

WR: Braylon E, Greg Jennings, Chambers, Curtis, Hardy

TE: Tony Gonzalez, Watson

K: Folk

DEF: Dallas

 

JoeBoxer

QB: Big Ben, Kitna

RB: ADP, Ryan Grant, Benson, A. Bradshaw, Foster

WR: Steve Smith, S. Holmes, D. Branch, Gage, Bryant Johnson

TE: Heath Miller

K: Graham

DST: San Diego

 

worm

QB: McNabb, Delhomme

RB: Westy, MJD, B. Jacobs, Deuce, Leon Washington

WR: Colston, Roy Williams, Driver, Bruce, Curry

TE: O. Daniels

K: Crosby

DEF: Seattle

 

mzf5c5

QB: Brady, Russell

RB: J. Lewis, Edge, A. Green, Felix Jones, K. Watson

WR: TJ Housh, Ward, Mason, Toomer, Wilford

TE: Dallas Clark

K: Bironas

DEF: Indy

 

Yippie

QB: Hasselbeck, A. Smith

RB: Steven Jackson, Reggie Bush, Forte, Chris Johnson, Ricky Williams

WR: Welker, Bowe, Berrian, Gaffney

TE: Gates, Crumpler

K: Dawson

DEF: Jax

 

Hardball

QB: Romo, Schaub

RB: Addai, Maroney, Mendenhall, Perry

WR: B.Marshall, Calvin Johnson, V. Jackson, R. Meacham, Hester, Sweed

TE: Cooley

K: Vinatieri

DST: Minnesota

 

Clash

QB: P.Manning, T. Edwards

RB: Gore,Turner, Kevin Smith, Norwood, Dunn

WR: Holt, L. Coles, J. Walker, Reggie Brown, Reggie Williams

TE: Kellen Winslow II

K: Rackers

DEF: New England

 

Feeling MN

QB: Bulger, Garrard

RB: Portis, R.Brown, T.Jones, S Young, Sammy Morris

WR: Fitz, Plaxico, S. Moss, A. Gonzalez, Booker

TE: V. Davis

K: Gould

DEF: Baltimore

 

Sweetness_34

QB: P Rivers, A. Rodgers

RB: M.Lynch, D. McFadden, Rudi, J.Stewart

WR: A. Johnson, Ocho Cinco, Engram, K. Walter, Ginn Jr.

TE: Shockey, G. Olsen

DEF: Bears

 

MTSkiBum

QB: Cutler, Leinart

RB: MBIII, E.Graham, L.White, L. Betts, Hightower

WR: Wayne, Boldin, Cotchery, S. Rice, Burleson, Mark Clayton

TE: Scheffler

 

pauld

QB: C. Palmer

RB: L. Johnson, W. McGahee, D. Williams, C. Brown, R. Rice

WR: Lee Evans, R.White, Galloway, J Porter, D Stallworth, Hackett

TE: Witten

DEF: Philly

 

SMath

QB: D. Anderson, E Manning

RB: FWP, Julius Jones, Henry, Fargas, Torain

WR: R.Moss, TO, Harrison, P Crayton

TE: Heap

K: Gostkowski

DEF: Pittsburgh

 

I didnt have the worst team of this mock draft, that title goes to either hardball, Smath, pauld, or sweetness.

 

Worm and Clash had the best draft's imo.

[mzf5c5 0]

I didnt have the worst team of this mock draft, that title goes to either hardball, Smath, pauld, or sweetness.

 

Worm and Clash had the best draft's imo.

 

you could add mine to the worst part, but I think you need to add Feeling MN to the best, He was weak at QB, but his other positions had good players in it.