Fair Deal?

[jls8421 3]

I offered Warner, T. Jones, L. Washington, C. Perry, E. Royal, and Buff D.

for

Kitna, Gore and Giants D.

 

I have Delhomme, Chris Johnson, Portis, S. Smith, L. Evans and R. Moss. So I'm really just giving up depth. The swap on Defs just gets me over the bye week.

 

Is this a fair deal?

[DexterMorgan 5]

Warner, Junk, Junk, Junk, Junk, Junk

 

For

 

Gore , Giants D, Junk

 

makes it a little easier to evaluate

[jls8421 3]

Warner, Junk, Junk, Junk, Junk, Junk

 

For

 

Gore , Giants D, Junk

 

makes it a little easier to evaluate

 

Lol, you're not to far off but in our system Buff D is actually ahead of the Giants D. and I think T. Jones schedule eases up quite a bit. He has Cinn, Oak, KC Buff, and Stl in the next 5 weeks. I don't know maybe I'm over thinking it.

[WhiteWonder 2,734]

I offered Warner, T. Jones, L. Washington, C. Perry, E. Royal, and Buff D.

for

Kitna, Gore and Giants D.

 

I have Delhomme, Chris Johnson, Portis, S. Smith, L. Evans and R. Moss. So I'm really just giving up depth. The swap on Defs just gets me over the bye week.

 

Is this a fair deal?

 

dont listen to that guy. Its actually

 

Warner, Jones, Royal, Junk, Junk, Junk

 

for

 

Gore, Junk, Junk

 

I list all defense as junk because right now because aside from Chicago and Tennessee, the next 9 defenses have a gap of about 12 or 13 fantasy points total thru 5 weeks and unless teams in your league are stashing 2 D's each there are plenty of waiver wire gems from week to week.

 

Jones and Royal as junk? Jones is still putting up about 10 fantasy pts per game, is a starting NFL RB and seems to be on an emerging high powered offense.. (also check out his sched). And Royal altho currently hurt looked pretty good prior to injury and should be back in what 2-3 weeks?

[jls8421 3]

Thanks, I guess my question still stands. Is this a fair deal?

[TennisMenace 156]

Warner for Gore and Giants D.

 

If I'm you, I would not want to trade Warner because he's been butter and has all those WRs to play with.

 

You don't really need Gore, but he is an upgrade over your 2 RB (obviously not Portis).

 

The Giants D is an upgrade but Buffalo's D/ST are solid except last week in the Arizona heat. Don't put much stock in that.

 

Bottom line if I'm you - no way Jose!

[jls8421 3]

Thanks anyone else have a say about this one?

[anty63 0]

pull the trigger

[LandenChase 0]

No, stay put. Giving up too much for Gore and the Giants D. Kitna and Detriot are a mess. Warner has too many weapons!

[jls8421 3]

pull the trigger

 

I'm guessing that means fair, lol.

 

any one else?

[fatty98 1]

It's fair, though I would prefer to have your end of the deal, just because of the value a stud (Gore) brings.

 

Thanks for mine.

[34payton34 0]

thanks for mine.

I would not do it. You would be giving up too much and essentially just getting Gore in return.

[Cstriker 2]

Kitna????? Why on earth would you want that guy?

[Reality 3,121]

Gore is 2nd among RB's by 1 point in my PPR league.

 

Guess it depends on your scoring format, but I would love to get my hands on Gore. I would trade Warner and never ever look back.

[Hermes 0]

I live in Detroit. All the local radio shows are saying that Kitna is on the verge of losing his job. This season is pretty much done for the Lions and it seems as though Kitna has given up on the team (probably understandably). I wouldn't want Kitna and Delhome as my QBs. I'd stay put unless you know you can get a better QB somewhere else.