PPR Keeper League trade help

[doc005 0]

In a PPR keeper league, should I make this trade?

 

I get:

Clinton Portis RB WAS

Maurice Jones-Drew RB JAC

 

 

I give:

LaDainian Tomlinson RB SD

Steve Smith WR CAR

[WhiteWonder 2,738]

nah

[The Next Generation 10]

Depends on the rest of your roster/keepers.

[Stewburtx8 67]

In a PPR keeper league, should I make this trade?

 

I get:

Clinton Portis RB WAS

Maurice Jones-Drew RB JAC

I give:

LaDainian Tomlinson RB SD

Steve Smith WR CAR

 

 

I'd definitely do it depending on the rest of your roster. I think MJD may be the top back in ppr leagues. Portis is also solid. Love LT for a bounce back but im just not a HUGE Steve Smith fan. But this question depends a lot more on the rest of your roster and your league starting requirements, etc.

[Ray_T 753]

In a PPR keeper league, should I make this trade?

 

I get:

Clinton Portis RB WAS

Maurice Jones-Drew RB JAC

I give:

LaDainian Tomlinson RB SD

Steve Smith WR CAR

 

 

for PPR I like this deal.

 

You give up LT and get portis. Both players are similar age and probably have a similar shelf life. (I think portis is 1 year younger but has been oft injured so there are harder miles on the odometer, so I consider them both equal that way)

 

LT should provide more fantasy points than portis. Probably by 1 or 2 fantasy points per game.

but now you also get MJD for Steve Smith. I think you make up for the loss of LT and get a franchise player to build around.

 

I'd seriously consider the deal only because this is a keeper league.

[Little Big Head 6]

id probably take the MJD side but try and flip Portis for a WR comparable to SSmith