Do I trade Jordy Nelson and Barnidge for Marshall and Jordan Reed? PPR

[eaglesfreak 10]

We start QB- RB- RB/WR -WR - WR- WR/RB/TE- k- def

 

QB

Ryan

Brady

 

RB

Latavious Murray

Deangelo WIlliams

Gio Bernard

Abdullah

Duke Johnson

 

WR

Beckham

Nelson

Cooks

Edelman

Garcon

Aiken

 

TE

Barnidge

 

Thoughts?

[bfros 53]

hell yes.

Marshall and Jordy are very close in my opinion. You are already strong at WR. And Reed is a definite upgrade over Barnidge, even with McCown coming back.

[jimaveli 119]

Keep the Jordy.

 

Understand that Kirk, while really good when he's good, can bonk his whole team in real and fantasy football when whe has a bad game. You just saw it Monday night.

 

Assume that Gary will have better days.

 

And from what I can tell, you don't have to start a tight end? If I'm right on that, don't do it. Healthy Jordy is in a grand situation and could heavily outdo midrange expectations.

[weepaws 2,461]

I like Reed more so yes.

[Machismo 0]

If you're being offered that, then yes, do it.

 

If you're the one making the offer, that's fine, but I don't know why the other owner would do that deal, at this point.

 

Marshall and Jordy could be a wash, but as for now, Marshall is the better WR because we don't fully know how Jordy will do this season; and while Barnidge should see a bump with McCown starting, Reed is still more valuable. So the other owner, more than likely, would be making his team worse.

 

It's just too early in the season.

[Cuse9 128]

Jump on this one. You get Reed and Marshall....do it in a heartbeat.