J Herbert for Saunders & Pittman?

[Boston_Diablo 0]

My team in a PPR

QB - Brady, Carr

RB - A Jones, M Saunders, E Elliot, D Foreman, C Patterson (IR)

WR - J Jefferson, B Ayiuk, M Pittman, A Robinson, G Pickens, W Robinson

TE - Weller, Engram

Would you trade Brady, Pittman and Saunders for J Herbert and G Wilson?

[weepaws 3,158]

No, I think that’s to much for a Qb. 

[himmystyles 30]

I wouldn’t do it. 

[easilyscan 870]

You're obviously loaded @ RB (especially if CP returns as planned week 10

Brady Vs Herbert. If you look at the stats, they're somewhat similar, especially total passing yards.

I can see where Brady only having 9 touchdowns in 8 games is a concern, but point out that Herbert, with 12 TDs in 7 games isn't exactly setting the world on fire himself.

1.71 TD's per game, which adds up to a total of 29.07 in a complete 17 game season. 

According to the scoring shown below, Herbert is averaging 3.3 points more than Brady per week.

Bottom line is that I tend to agree the advice already given. But if you think Herbert is going to improve & Brady is going to deteriorate further, go ahead and make the deal.

 

 

 

FFToday Standard Scoring: Review Scoring

My FFToday   > Pre-Set Scoring     FFToday Standard    FFToday Half-PPR    FFToday PPR    ESPN    Yahoo!    FFPC    Fanduel    Underdog    CBS Sports    NFL.com    NFFC

Passing Rushing Fantasy Player Sort First:     Last:   Team   G   Comp   Att   Yard   TD   INT   Att   Yard   TD   FPts   FPts/G    1. Josh Allen BUF 7 173 264 2,198 19 6 53 306 2 228.5 32.6  2. Joe Burrow CIN 8 211 305 2,329 17 6 31 132 3 215.7 27.0  3. Lamar Jackson BAL 8 148 235 1,635 15 6 75 553 2 209.1 26.1  4. Patrick Mahomes KC 7 176 263 2,159 20 5 21 113 0 199.3 28.5  5. Jalen Hurts PHI 7 141 211 1,789 10 2 77 306 6 196.1 28.0  6. Kyler Murray ARI 8 215 325 1,993 10 6 51 299 2 181.6 22.7  7. Geno Smith SEA 8 181 249 1,924 13 3 35 158 1 170.0 21.3  8. Trevor Lawrence JAC 8 173 277 1,838 10 6 27 99 3 159.8 20.0  9. Marcus Mariota ATL 8 112 178 1,432 10 6 55 280 3 157.6 19.7  10. Justin Herbert LAC 7 203 308 2,009 12 4 21 48 0 153.3 21.9  11. Tom Brady TB 8 224 340 2,267 9 1 12 -5 0 148.9 18.6