Keeper Question

[Da_Bears 14]

We are allowed to keep 1 player from last year’s draft from round 10 - 16.

The player kept is that rounds player for this years draft.

Player cannot be kept in back to back years

‘So, I drafted Mattison in round 10 and Lawrence in round 16.

[Ray_T 752]

nice problem to have.

what are the rules of your league?   is it PPR?  or Standard scoring?    any unique features to the league that would affect the way we value a QB?

[Da_Bears 14]

Half PPR for RB standard yardage pts. 4pt for QB TDs and standard yardage pts.

[Ray_T 752]

while it is tempting to get Lawrence, he is the 10th ranked QB on the board.   which could mean he may slide later into the draft.

while I think he has the potential do do better than #10, the cost to re acquire should still be lower than Mattison.   interestingly enough, when I checked fantasy pros, the ADP of both is almost the same.

at the end of the day what it really comes down to is what your preference is...

from a positional scarcity standpoint, RB is more rare.    Most leagues have 2 RB starting slots, and Mattison is the 11th ranked RB based on ADP.

Most leagues only start 1 QB and Lawrence on average is the 8th QB off the board.  if you dont keep him Aaron Rodgers and Kirk Cousins are ranked #12 and #13 and could possibly out produce Lawrence this year. (both did last year)

further down the list is Russell Wilson, Derek Carr and Stafford. 

see what I mean?   and these guys likely have double digit Draft positions.

unless you think Lawrence is a top 5 QB you probably shouldnt keep him.

Just my opinion.

I would keep Mattison.

 

[weepaws 3,165]

Lawrence and there is no second choice.