Keeper question. Tyreek or Puka

[GoonCrew 2]

New keeper league. We only keep one keeper. You lose corresponding pick of where drafted previous year. I have pick 1.5 in 12 team ppr. 
If I keep Tyreek I lose pick 5. 
If I keep Puka I only lose late round pick since UDFA and get to keep pick 5, who I can probably grab whoever is left between Tyreek, Chase, Hall, Bijan, Jefferson 

[weepaws 3,167]

I’m not sure I understand, why would you lose Hill, and the 5th pick if you keep Hill? 

[GoonCrew 2]

That was a typo. I fixed it. 
I meant if I keep Puka, I most likely lose hill unless he fell to 5 (unlikely)

[weepaws 3,167]

I like Hill over those others, so I’ll keep Hill. 

[GoonCrew 2]

I guess my question is:

is Puka/Chase > than just Hill

or Puka/Hall > Hill

[BigDaddy1978 0]

On 8/13/2024 at 10:42 PM, GoonCrew said:

I guess my question is:

is Puka/Chase > than just Hill

or Puka/Hall > Hill

Yes and yes

I would keep Puka, who's going back to the same offense and whose value is WAY higher coming in the late rounds (which is where all FF leagues are won). 

And then you can draft a commensurate player to Hill to accompany him. And if that player is Ja'Mar Chase or Breece Hall or even potentially get Hill back, I don't see a problem. 

[Ray_T 752]

picking at #5, you can very easily end up with the guy you were gonna keep in the first place.   you may get lucky and get someone better.   I like your options at 5.   I'd keep Puka.

[Super Cubs 154]

i'd keep puka