Trade Help

[kac1 0]

this was just proposed to me..

 

I get:

Garcia

T.Jones

 

I give:

Barber III

V.Jackson

 

Current roster:

QB: (start 2) McNabb, Rivers, Warner

RB: Addai, Parker, Barber, B.Jacobs

WR: Roy Williams, V.Jackson, Edwards, Holmes, Bowe

TE: Witten, Des. Clark

K: Folk

DEF: (start 2) Arizona, Minnesota, Tennessee

 

Some of the scoring for the league:

Completions (1)

Passing Yards (20 yards per point; 3 points at 300 yards; 5 points at 400 yards)

Passing Touchdowns (6)

Interceptions (-1)

Rushing Yards (10 yards per point; 3 points at 150 yards; 5 points at 200 yards; 10 points at 250 yards)

Rushing Touchdowns (6)

Receptions (1)

Reception Yards (15 yards per point; 2 points at 100 yards; 4 points at 150 yards; 6 points at 200 yards)

Reception Touchdowns (6)

 

Do I make this trade? The other owner also has QB's of Anderson and Griese to go along with garcia.

[notJames 0]

No.

 

I don't see Garcia doing any better than the QBs you have. And giving up MBIII for Jones would be a crime.

 

Personally, I don't see what you would gain with this.

 

Hope that helps. Now, maybe you can help me out...

[kac1 0]

What if I countered with Barber/Jackson for Anderson/Jones. Would that be unfair?

[rpmbcs 0]

I would not do it. Garcia should not do any better than what you have. I know he throws for a lot of yards but he also throws a lot of balls to the other team. They should pick up on the running game with grahm so he won't have to throw as much.

 

 

I just don't see this improving your team. I would not trade MBIII

[uxb666 0]

I'd rather have Barber on my roster come playoff time, you never know with injuries. Garcia just doesn't give you much of a bump to make losing Barber worth it.

[kac1 0]

What if I countered with Anderson instead of Garcia.

[Litig8r 0]

Keep your current roster ... I would not give up the beast barbarian for what you have tossed up as alternatives. Just my 2c

[ppierce 2]

no way

[samsquirrel 0]

thanks for mine.

 

i'd stay pat if i were you.

[ric0 23]

i'd hold.

 

thanks for mine.

[Connorsdad 38]

No keep the players you have.

 

Thanks for answering mine and Goodluck!!

[kac1 0]

I turned down the trade and he proposed another..

 

I get:

Garcia

T.Jones

 

I give:

B.Jacobs

V.Jackson

 

Do I decline this one?

[Guest ramrock11]

HOLD

[PunkRockRedneck 8]

I don't see how Garcia would be helping you. I think you're better off keeping what you got here. I'd say no thanks.

[kac1 0]

Do you guys think D.Anderson would be an upgrade over what I have now instead of Garcia?

[NotAClue 0]

I think Anderson would definitely be an upgrade. He has several fantastic matchups coming up, especially during playoffs.

 

The problem is #1) is it enough of an upgrade to lose Marion Barber and #2) will he be the starter for the rest of the year.

 

#1) I think Warner is going to put up excellent numbers with a strong offense and good schedule. So I think Anderson would prolly net you on average 8-10 points a week more than Warner (during weeks of good matchup).

 

#2) I have no idea what the QB situation in Cleveland is. If you can pin down whether he'll be the starter for the rest of the year, then it'd be fine.

 

 

Overall, if you're ahead of the pack in terms of making it into the FF playoffs, I'd stay put. However, if you need help to make it into the running, I'd prolly trade for Anderson.

 

Thanks for mine.

[BostonPatriots 0]

I am not doing this trade if I was you. You are not getting enough for MBIII. He is a beast right now in a RBBC. Imagine what he would do if J. Jones gets hurt, or Dallas wakes up and realizes to use MBIII more.

 

Thanks for mine, sorry for the long waited response. I was travelling for work today.