t.j 35 Posted May 3, 2006 RBs are always the hot topic, but one QB can make or break your team. List your top 30 QBs, based on the following scoring system. Keep in mind this is dynasty, not just for this year. 6 points per TD 1 point per 20 passing yards, 1 point per 10 rushing yards -2 per INT, -2 per fumble The way I'll score it is 30pts for your #1 QB down to 1pt for your #30 QB. If you only rank say 20 QBs I'll count 20pts for your #1 QB down to 1pt for your #20 QB. Here's mine: 1. Peyton Manning (breaking records every year) 2. Tom Brady (reliable) 3. Carson Palmer (as long as his knee recovers) 4. Eli Manning (making strides, plenty of targets) 5. Ben Roethlisberger (carried Pitt to the Super Bowl) 6. Donovan McNabb (back to the pre-TO days) 7. Matt Hasselbeck (no Hutch = more passing?) 8. Byron Leftwich (JSmith and 4 good young targets) 9. Daunte Culpepper (no comment) 10. Marc Bulger (productive but fragile) 11. Mike Vick (see Bulger) 12. Jake Delhomme (top 5-10 this year) 13. Drew Brees (not many targets outside of Bush and aging Horn) 14. David Carr (pass blocking still a question mark) 15. Vince Young (Chow/Fisher) 16. Jay Cutler (great match with Shanahan) 17. Matt Leinart (a Warner injury away) 18. Drew Bledsoe (top 5-10 this year) 19. Philip Rivers (sleeper?) 20. Charlie Frye (good opportunity if he beats out Dilfer) 21. Kellen Clemens (probably starting by '07) 22. Rex Grossman (getting into the risky guys) 23. Trent Green (1 year left? 2?) 24. Alex Smith (big Vernon helps) 25. Aaron Brooks (feed the WRs) 26. Jake Plummer (4 years left on his deal, but has to perform) 27. Chris Simms (good: Gruden, bad: Rattay, Gradkowski) 28. Matt Schaub (not a Falcon beyond 2007) 29. Kurt Warner (holds off Leinart until he gets hurt) 30. Brodie Croyle (although Gonzo might not outlast Green) Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Portis26 0 Posted May 3, 2006 dynasty league ... id put Leinart over the other Rookie Qbs and no love for Jason Campbell Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ERIC-THE-RED 0 Posted May 3, 2006 1-P.MANNING 2-C.PALMER 3-T.BRADY 4-E.MANNING 5-D.McNABB 6-M.BULGER 7-J.DELHOMME 8-M.VICK (micheal) 9-M.HASSLEBACK 10-B.ROETHLISBERGER these are my top 10. culpeper is not in because of a new team and bum knee. favre is slowly getting worse. McNABB and bulger are high because of the style of offence ( alot of passing). Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
t.j 35 Posted May 3, 2006 I'm a lot more interested in 11-30 than the top 10 so please make the extra effort if you can. And keep in mind that this is for dynasty, not redraft. I think you can make a good case for Campbell and a bunch of other guys over Croyle (especially with KC's future WRs/TEs an unknown), but I think Campbell has too many question marks to go any higher than that. He has to prove himself to Gibbs before FF players can count on him. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Darb33 0 Posted May 3, 2006 It's pretty early but I will try to fly through this quickly: 1)Peyton Manning 2)Carson Palmer 3)Eli Manning 4)Tom Brady 5)Donovan McNabb 6)Matt Hasselbeck 7)Jake Delhomme 8)Ben Roethlisberger 9)Byron Leftwich 10)Daunte Culpepper 11)Marc Bulger 12)David Carr 13)Drew Brees 14)Trent Green 15)Mike Vick 16)Jake Plummer 17)Aaron Brooks 18)Matt Leinart 19)Mark Brunell 20)Josh McCown 21)Matt Schaub 22)David Gerard 23)Jay Cutler 24)Chris Simms 25)Chad Pennington 26)Drew Bledsoe 27)Brad Johnson 28)Billy Volek 29)Charlie Frye 30)JP Losman Sorry if I forgot a name, i did this pretty fast. It doesn't look too bad though I don't think. Edit- I see I forgot Phillip Rivers, Aaron Rodgers and Alex Smith. All should probably go in the 20's somewhere. I might have missed Favre as well, but since he is basically on a 1 year deal, I don't know if he even belongs in the top 30. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Dr. Octopus 0 Posted May 3, 2006 1. Peyton Manning 2. Carson Palmer 3. Donovan McNabb 4. Tom Brady 5. Eli Manning 6. Matt Hasselbeck 7. Marc Bulger 8. Daunte Culpepper 9. Michael Vick 10. Phillip Rivers 11. Drew Brees 12. Ben Roethlisberger 13. Jake Plummer 14. Jake Delhomme 15. Byron Leftwhich 16. David Carr 17. Matt Leinart 18. Chris Simms 19. Drew Bledsoe 20. Charlie Frye 21. Kurt Warner 22. Aaron Brooks 23. Vince Young 24. Trent Green 25. Josh McCown 26. Patrick Ramsey 27. Aaron Rodgers 28. Kyle Boeller 29. Alex Smith 30. Steve McNair Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
mozzy84 0 Posted May 3, 2006 1 Peyton Manning 2 Carson Palmer 3 Donovan McNabb 4 Tom Brady 5 Eli Manning 6 Matt Hasselbeck 7 Daunte Culpepper 8 Drew Brees 9 Michael Vick 10 Marc Bulger 11 Jake Delhomme 12 Ben Roethlisberger 13 Philip Rivers 14 Matt Lienart 15 David Carr 16 Drew Bledsoe 17 Byron Leftwich 18 Jake Plummer 19 Trent Green 20 Vince young 21 Aaron Brooks 22 Kyle Boller 23 Josh McCown 24 Brad Johnson 25 Rex Grossman 26 Steve McNair 27 Brett Favre 28 Mark Brunell 29 Charlie Frye 30 Kurt Warner alex smith, Losman, Rogers, Simms, Cutler, , Pennington, Ramsey, Collins and Volek could probably be put in place of some of the last names here, just depends who you like. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
jdon 28 Posted May 4, 2006 1. Peyton manning - no edge, more passing tds 2. Carson Palmer - I actually think their tough schedule will demand more passing out of him 3. Jake Delhomme 4. Hasselback - they play noone, plus the addition of burleson 30 tds and 3500 yards should be easy 5. Vick - I see good numbers for him this year 6. Bulger 7. Eli - could go higher but I don't know if he is ready just yet. 8. Bledsoe 9. The combo of Warner/Leinart 10. Simms 11. Culpepper 12. Lions QBs - Kitna could be good, believe it. 13. McNabb - I hate mcnabb 14. Roethlisberger 15. brees 16. Leftwhich Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
