Tyler Thigpen: Who are you starting him over?

[RockyTop 0]

Talk amongst yourselves.

[WhoDat 1]

Drew Brees.... nuff said..

[Kingstowne Dealers 14]

I'm waffling over starting him over Romo. MMMmmmm this Kool-Aid tastes delicious!

[njkrauss 0]

i would start brees, but i'm thinking about sitting romo too.

[The Bag-O-Bones 5]

Pigpen over Schuab

[WHODAT in AZ 0]

Thigpen over Pennington, Garcia and Sage lol =) talk about a QB controversy.

[Dont_Fook_Wit_me 0]

Well i drafted Big Ben and have been very loyal to him untill now...Im done with his ######... Im starting Thigpin over Big Ben, Campbell, and culpepper...I also had the chance to trade for either matt Ryan or Quinn and i chose to start him over both them to...I think this guy is the real deal and having LJ back cant hurt him, but only help...

[vroompac 2]

Using him over McNabb. Did it last week and they both had 3 TDs but Pigpen did a tad better.

[brotherbock 349]

This is a question of interest to me.

 

I'm in a keeper league, and I just traded yesterday for Matt Ryan. I grabbed Thigpen last weekend, and I was planning on starting him over Big Ben and Campbell. I originally traded for Ryan purely as keeper material, but I've been thinking (overthinking) about this week. Thigpen has the Saints, but Ryan has Denver.

 

I think they'll be pretty close, but any little bit helps. What do you guys think, Thigpen or Ryan this week? Definately not Campbell or Big Ben over either of them.

[xenophobe 1]

Between he and Rodgers for me as well. I haven't decided, but he is really making this a tough choice.

[RamslovaMartzhata 3]

Thigpen gets the nod over Campbell and Rosenfels until further notice. Spread offense for the FFL win.

[1KCfanNVA 0]

Thigpen gets the start over Tony Romo and Brady Quinn this week...Thigpen will light up the NO defense...Sleeper at WR this week is Marc Bradley...

[EAwer 1]

fock tough decision: dellhomme vs detroit!! or thigpen...

[Borat33 17]

fock tough decision: dellhomme vs detroit!! or thigpen...

 

Same here, I just acquired both and now I have no clue who to start?

[brotherbock 349]

Same here, I just acquired both and now I have no clue who to start?

 

Between those two, I'd go with Thigpen. It's unclear how effective LJ is going to be, just coming back to the team. They've changed the offense pretty significantly since he's been out. What is clear is that the Carolina running game is going to play big. To me that says that Thigpen will have more of the game on his shoulders than Delhomme will.

 

I may have just answered my own dilemma between Thigpen and Ryan, too. Denver is much worse against the run than New Orleans is. I may be starting Thigpen over Matt Ryan this week.

[Sgt_Russia 0]

Thigpen has been a very nice surprise, for sure. I'd have no problems starting him over Campbell, but I'd think twice about starting him over Delhomme, Big Ben, Pennington. If you start him over Romo, Rodgers, McNabb, you need to have your head examined. It is possible to over-think in this game.

 

That's not a knock on Thigpen or his favorable match-up and I'm in no way guaranteeing that anyone will outscore anyone. But if you make the decision to go with the new hot player, over time, you'll more than likely get bitten right in the ass.

[Borat33 17]

Between those two, I'd go with Thigpen. It's unclear how effective LJ is going to be, just coming back to the team. They've changed the offense pretty significantly since he's been out. What is clear is that the Carolina running game is going to play big. To me that says that Thigpen will have more of the game on his shoulders than Delhomme will.

 

I may have just answered my own dilemma between Thigpen and Ryan, too. Denver is much worse against the run than New Orleans is. I may be starting Thigpen over Matt Ryan this week.

 

Good points, also the Saints-Chiefs game will prob be a shootout while CAR just steamrolls the Lions.

[1KCfanNVA 0]

Same here, I just acquired both and now I have no clue who to start?

 

 

Get Thiggy wit it!!!!!!

[BiPolarBear 485]

I have him in over Rivers. If he tanks I will never live it down.

[1KCfanNVA 0]

Between those two, I'd go with Thigpen. It's unclear how effective LJ is going to be, just coming back to the team. They've changed the offense pretty significantly since he's been out. What is clear is that the Carolina running game is going to play big. To me that says that Thigpen will have more of the game on his shoulders than Delhomme will.

 

I may have just answered my own dilemma between Thigpen and Ryan, too. Denver is much worse against the run than New Orleans is. I may be starting Thigpen over Matt Ryan this week.

 

A friendly "way to go" says Thiggy out-scores Romo this weekend...

[njkrauss 0]

its decisions like thiggy over romo which make ffb fun.

[AintNoStoppinMeNow 68]

Starting him over Eli Manning who's against the Ravens.

[PunkRockRedneck 8]

I'm seriously considering him over Rivers. Thigpens matchup is just too tempting.

[brotherbock 349]

A friendly "way to go" says Thiggy out-scores Romo this weekend...

 

I don't thig I'll take the odds against that. Romo's bound to be rusty, Witten's banged up, and TO's an aging toad. I also thig Thig's got a chance to outscore Romo.