Antonio / Duke Johnson for Marvin Jones / Lamar Miller?

[jrbdmb 28]

I've got an offer of my Antonio / Duke Johnson for Marvin Jones / Lamar Miller.

 

Other than Antonio I'm meh at WR: Fitz, Sammie Coates, and Tyrell Williams. (Lost both Decker and Watkins to IR.)

But my RBs are brutal: Jeremy Hill, Jon Stewart, Duke, and Dwayne Washington.

 

Is it worth giving up the best WR in the game to get much better at RB?

[jimaveli 119]

It's tough. For this to work you have to fully believe in lame-r Miller to get it together and be a top 15 rb most weeks and a top 5 a few weeks. You have to believe the same thing about sweet sweet Marvin Jones.

 

And even then, a tear would roll down your cheek every time Antonio drops a 30 and outscores both Miller and Marvin in a week.

 

Its close and logical but I'm still not ready to advocate giving up Brown without it being a more clear haul.

[jrokh 608]

I'd want a better RB for antonio one of the top 5 guys

[weepaws 3,158]

Miller hasn't been much this season.

 

Nope I'm not trading Brown.

[mcgruber 17]

i would never give up brown, only trade for brown.

 

the trade would have to be pretty lopsided for me to even consider it.

[kobe808lak 7]

If it was something like Jones + Shady or Jones + Gurley then I would.

[jrbdmb 28]

Yeah, even though I think the trade is fairly even I know you almost always want to trade *for* the best player in the deal, not trade *away* the best player. Not that I'm getting garbage back, but I guess if someone wants Antonio that much they need to overpay.