Do I give up Ronnie Brown for Peyton

[dpollaro 0]

Guy who picked before me is offering me peyton for ronnie brown..(i receive peyton)

 

6 pts for all TDs. Look at my team and let me know.

 

Starters

 

QB Kurt Warner

RB Ronnie Brown

RB Cadillac Williams

WR Santana Moss

WR Andre Johnson

Flex Jamal Lewis

Flex Travis Henry

Flex Jason Witten

K Mike Vanderjagt

Def Atlanta

TE Todd Heap

 

Bench

QB Drew Bledsoe

RB Wali Lundy

RB Joseph Addai

RB Chris Brown

RB Michael Bennett

WR Donte Stallworth

WR Amani Toomer

WR Cedrick Wilson

WR Brandon Stokley

 

 

Should I do this? We can start many rb's in this league due to flex.

 

Please leave link

[piget 0]

I would not. Warner/Bledsoe combo should be on par with Manning. Think about getting Lienert and Romo for 2 of your bench players.

[joeyt7 1]

I like the warner/bledsoe combo keep r brown.

[prostollo 0]

I wouldnt make the trade. One other suggestion just looking at your lineup I would start lundi over henry.

[Ray_T 600]

Guy who picked before me is offering me peyton for ronnie brown..(i receive peyton)

 

6 pts for all TDs. Look at my team and let me know.

 

Starters

 

QB Kurt Warner

RB Ronnie Brown

RB Cadillac Williams

WR Santana Moss

WR Andre Johnson

Flex Jamal Lewis

Flex Travis Henry

Flex Jason Witten

K Mike Vanderjagt

Def Atlanta

TE Todd Heap

 

Bench

QB Drew Bledsoe

RB Wali Lundy

RB Joseph Addai

RB Chris Brown

RB Michael Bennett

WR Donte Stallworth

WR Amani Toomer

WR Cedrick Wilson

WR Brandon Stokley

Should I do this? We can start many rb's in this league due to flex.

 

Please leave link

 

if you get 6 points for all TD's it's awfully tempting to make this deal cuz of the amount of TD passes manning will get.

 

However,

 

I dont like your depth at RB to make that deal. There are big question marks behind the names of every backup you have there, and it's actually possible that all 4 out of 4 of those wont be a starter for most of the season. While I agree a lot of them have potential and could be a full year starter, I wouldnt count on it.

 

I would counter with something like this:

 

Ronnie Brown and Kurt Warner (or Drew Bledsoe)

 

For

 

Peyton manning and a starting Calibre RB. (assuming he has one)

 

Unfortunately I dont know what other players he has on his team, so I cant help you much more. But I think a deal like this would make more sense for your team.

[Bottles 0]

While I don't love Warner and Petyon's obviously a huge upgrade, I would not lose your legt RB1. Otherwise you depend on Jamal Lewis, and you dont have much else depth. Suffer through with Warner.

[Bbronco 0]

I agree with the consensus, keep ronnie because you already have good depth at QB, and that would pretty much debilitate you at RB...thanks for the reply

[Rabid Wookie 0]

I think Peyton will have a huge year this year (his match-ups are great), but you just don't have the RBs to do this deal. Stick with what you've got.

[Bri114 0]

My initial reaction was to say do the trade...after all you can only start one QB, and Peyton is better than Warner or Bledsoe...but if Lundi gets hurt than you're kinda screwed. So I guess I agree with Ray T

[FantasyKing 4]

Guy who picked before me is offering me peyton for ronnie brown..(i receive peyton)

 

6 pts for all TDs. Look at my team and let me know.

 

Starters

 

QB Kurt Warner

RB Ronnie Brown

RB Cadillac Williams

WR Santana Moss

WR Andre Johnson

Flex Jamal Lewis

Flex Travis Henry

Flex Jason Witten

K Mike Vanderjagt

Def Atlanta

TE Todd Heap

 

Bench

QB Drew Bledsoe

RB Wali Lundy

RB Joseph Addai

RB Chris Brown

RB Michael Bennett

WR Donte Stallworth

WR Amani Toomer

WR Cedrick Wilson

WR Brandon Stokley

Should I do this? We can start many rb's in this league due to flex.

 

Please leave link

 

At first glance at your roster, I thought maybe you did not know what you were doing.

 

And then this confirmed it...

 

Should I do this? We can start many rb's in this league due to flex.

 

Why in hell would you do this when you have 2 solid QBs to pick from and you can start multilple RBs, and Brown is your best one?????

[SaintsInDome2006 128]

Just say no; you need one more decent RB. Trade a QB on a flier of a possible RB who might take off.

[dalie 2]

Keep Ronnie Brown

[lguero1 4]

geniuses think alike. these guys must be very smart.

[dpollaro 0]

bump

[ltpunk 0]

Too thin at RB to make this deal. Warner to Fitz and Boldin all year(barring inj.)

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=229036

[TAM2020 0]

You're RB depth is the key issue. Its not fantastic considering if you made the trade, Wali would be your starter (although he could be very good this year). Stick with your squad.

 

check out mine please

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=229043