Trade Evaluation

[Beyond Chaos 75]

Give: Leinart, L. Jordan, Horn, Engram

for: Holt, McCallister

 

 

start 2QBs, 2RBs, 3 WRs, 1 TE, 2 Ks, 1 D

 

my team: P. Manning, D. Brees, Losman, Leinart

W. Dunn, T. Bell, L. Jordan

Harrison, Horn, Ward, Jennings, Kennison, Engram

Gonzalez, Miller

Reed, Carney, Gostowski

Jax, NYGiants

 

 

is the above a good trade and he said he may counter with Addai and Holt instead is it still a good trade

 

the team i'm trading has no QBs this week and only 1 starter (Brady) for the rest of the season (Culpepper and Collins are now backups)

[AC/DC Anarchy 0]

I'd do it, Dunn and Bell have had their byes so barring injury, you don't need an extra RB

[buffandan 0]

Seems like a good trade to me. But don't let him counter and swap Addai for McCallister. I view the trade as Holt for Horn, and McCallister for Jordan, which seems like a net positive to me. Granted, I didn't pay attention to any bye week issues.

 

Mine:http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=243152

[bgard72 10]

I like that trade...getting Holt and Duece! And you're really not giving up too much for them.

 

Please see mine:

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=243106

[mrgymrat 0]

Yes, trade looks good for you. Like someone said "accept no McCallister substitutes". Holt would be a good pickup for you.

[Kam187 6]

If u can get Holt and Deuce for basically Horn then do it in a heartbeat. Sounds like he really is getting the worse end of the deal and dont understand why he would do it but if he really is willing to part with two studs, take the deal and run with it!!! Thanks for seeing mine

[jdizel 0]

Yes, I would do it

[JazzyJeff30 0]

definately a great deal for you. i wouldnt take it if he offered addai though unless it was a keeper league then i would have to think about it a little more.

[bflodan 0]

Its always a good idea to get Holt!!

McCalister would be sweet...I would do it either way...but if you get McCalister wow!!!

[BigTymeShocker 0]

id do it

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=243184

[j0novision 0]

I've got to give the thumbs up as well. You're okay at RB. Can't pass up Holt if he's willing to deal.

 

Jon

[redwolf 0]

Give: Leinart, L. Jordan, Horn, Engram

for: Holt, McCallister

start 2QBs, 2RBs, 3 WRs, 1 TE, 2 Ks, 1 D

 

my team: P. Manning, D. Brees, Losman, Leinart

W. Dunn, T. Bell, L. Jordan

Harrison, Horn, Ward, Jennings, Kennison, Engram

Gonzalez, Miller

Reed, Carney, Gostowski

Jax, NYGiants

is the above a good trade and he said he may counter with Addai and Holt instead is it still a good trade

 

the team i'm trading has no QBs this week and only 1 starter (Brady) for the rest of the season (Culpepper and Collins are now backups)

holt and mcalister are studs and you are not giving up much for them. take the trade.

[granta_05 3]

No doubt, do that one. You don't need Leinart, Deuce is an upgrade over Lamont, and Holt is better than Horn/Engram. Good deal for you.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=243201

[dd2005 0]

I like your trade - but do not trade out Addai for Mccalister - keep Mcallister in the deal - thanks for mine

[hagler 0]

Do the deal....

 

I like Deuce more than Addai, but still take Addai...

 

You give up guys that are only backups for you..

 

Holt + Harrison deadly down the stretch.

 

Please see mine:

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=243461

[hadji 0]

I would do that deal in a heartbeat. Rookie QB, McCallister is way better than Jordan at this point with the turmoil the Raiders are in, Horn is not the same receiver he has been in the past, Engram is going to be out for a while. You're getting one of the best WR's and a very good RB in McCallister. Great deal for you.