Another Keeper Quandry

[GDH88 0]

Landscape: 12 team, .5 PPR; 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR 2 keeper league, 1 Flex; 3 divisions of 4 teams. Division winners make playoffs, 3 others w/best records make playoffs. Other three Owners in my division not that strong managers. Keepers cost +2 draft picks from last season draft position.

 

Definitely keeping Jay Ajayi for 9.09 pick; struggling with these options looking at Draft Buddy, having entered all keepers, updated Projections & Rankings:

 

Option 1: Keep Melvin Gordon for 2.04 pick Locking in (2) RBs, not much value in keeper selection

Option 2: Keep Jameis Winston for 13.09 pick Seems to be the best value according to Draft Buddy

Option 3: Keep Darren McFadden for 14.04 pick Then, try to scoop Ezekiel Elliott with 2.04 pick; Risky but EZE beast when playoffs come; Won't make it past 2.12 selection due to keeper attractiveness next year.

Option 4: Keep Kelvin Benjamin for 11.09 pick Kept KB last year at 13.04 pick, good value but wasn’t what I expected circa 2014 performance

 

Keepers heading into draft are:

David Johnson , Odell Beckham, Mike Evans, Jordy Nelson, Freeman, Ajayi, Michael Thomas, Jordan Howard, Brady, Pryor, Adams, Crowell, Hill, Ryan, Woodhead, Ware, Mariota, Gillesee, Proisse, RKelly, Hunter Henry & Rishard Matthews.

 

Thanks in advance for your response.

 

 

[weepaws 3,158]

You must keep Gordon.

[Hawkeye21 2,382]

Gordon seems like the obvious choice.

[Kopy 559]

Gordon

[TBayXXXVII 2,486]

I agree with the above, Gordon.