Stafford for Crabtree...NEED HELP!

[rwockenf 0]

1pt PPR...QB TDs worth 4 pts. We start 1QB, 2RB, 2WR, and 2FLEX. My Team:

 

QB: Prescott, Luck

 

RB: Hunt, Crowell, Perkins, D. Martin

 

WR: Tate, Crabtree, D. Adams, T. Hill

 

TE: Rudolph

 

 

I posted on our league page that I was interested in upgrading at QB. Someone offered Mariota...I turned that down. This guy offered me Stafford for Crabtree. He also has Brees so I know he won't be hurting at QB. My question: Is Stafford a big enough upgrade over Prescott (obviously Luck is a big ?...and who knows how he'll be after he comes back.) that giving up Crabtree is worth it. Right now I am starting WRs in both FLEX spots...Thoughts? Also, our Roster restrictions are 2 QBs only...so I'd have to drop either Prescott or Luck if I added Stafford.

[Jarvis Basnight 119]

Not sure if you should do the trade but did you know Crabtree is better than Cooper?

[RaiderHaters Revenge 4,246]

no

 

why would you trade for Stafford when you can use the guys you have or Siemien, ASmith

[rwockenf 0]

Yeah I should have stated...Available QBs (and again, to add I would have to drop either Prescott or Luck) are:

 

Siemien

Goff

Glennon

McCown

Watson

etc

etc

 

 

I know Trevor is doing well...but would I necessarily drop Luck for Seimein? idk...

[mcgruber 17]

no chance i do that trade. You can always stream a QB if you don't like Dak's matchup. Crabtree will be a solid wr2 with wr1 upside most weeks.

[rwockenf 0]

To directly answer your question, I was initially throwing out the "upgrade QB" question just to see what offers I'd get...I don't really trust Luck...and with Dallas's Bye being Week 5 (I think), if Luck isn't ready, I'd have to drop him anyway...

[RaiderHaters Revenge 4,246]

I would drop Luck for Siemien today

 

I would then use Goff over Prescott if needed

[rwockenf 0]

I would drop Luck for Siemien today

 

I would then use Goff over Prescott if needed

Can I ask the logic behind the Luck for Siemien decision? I'm not disagreeing...I'm just curious about why you believe that.

[datwaymon 8]

Looking at your roster and your streaming choices there's no way I'd make that trade.

[seafoam1 2,810]

Can I ask the logic behind the Luck for Siemien decision? I'm not disagreeing...I'm just curious about why you believe that.

Is Indi gonna win a game before he comes back? Probably not. They have no reason to rush him back. Hell, they should sit him the whole year and get a top 2 pick next year. Draft the best OL availible in the first 4 rounds, and pray they work out.

[Ray_T 740]

Yeah I should have stated...Available QBs (and again, to add I would have to drop either Prescott or Luck) are:

 

Siemien

Goff

Glennon

McCown

Watson

etc

etc

 

 

I know Trevor is doing well...but would I necessarily drop Luck for Seimein? idk...

I dont know that I'd be jumping all over that trade. The price is pretty high.

 

I'd strongly consider picking up Goff or Siemien.

 

all of Cousin's good production came as a part of a McVay Offense with him as Co-ordinator.

 

I think Goff will produce under McVay and you wont be disappointed with him if you grab him.

 

that being said.... if you feel the risk is too high with Goff Siemien provides less risk but also less upside (in my opinion) and he is a reasonable option.

 

He's no Stafford, but you also dont have to pay a huge price for him.

 

At the end of the day, it is possible that Prescott may actually be the best QB of the bunch, and if Stafford outscores him I dont think it will be by a lot. for that reason, I think it's tough to pay such a high price (Crabtree) to get Stafford. I'm not sure your QB production will increase enough to justify the decrease you will have at WR.

[rwockenf 0]

Yeah that's fair. I went ahead and grabbed Trevor and dropped Luck. Thanks all.