Waller? or Kittle?

[Ray_T 740]

who do you value most in a trade?

I had kittle in one league and had someone outside the league ask me if I'd trade him for Waller.    I actually had to think about it.

thought this might be a good question to poll the boys on.

Who do you like better?

[polecatt 474]

They're about the same, I would say pick whichever one is healthy, but they're both game time decision to start the season

[weepaws 3,154]

No

[GobbleDog 984]

I'd definitely trade Kittle for Waller. Kittle has a habit of disappearing for chunks of the season. Niners are a run-first team led by Brock Purdy (jury still out) - and Ayuik should take a step forward this year getting more targets, I'd expect Kittle's disappearing acts to continue. Waller should be more consistent. When ya need points most at the end of the season to make the playoffs or move on to next round, ya want the most reliable player. That's Waller.

Of course, that takes on Waller's hammy issues, which is the downside - but the only reason you're getting the offer. I'd assume that risk for the upside.

[shorepatrol 1,870]

6 hours ago, GobbleDog said:

I'd definitely trade Kittle for Waller. Kittle has a habit of disappearing for chunks of the season. Niners are a run-first team led by Brock Purdy (jury still out) - and Ayuik should take a step forward this year getting more targets, I'd expect Kittle's disappearing acts to continue. Waller should be more consistent. When ya need points most at the end of the season to make the playoffs or move on to next round, ya want the most reliable player. That's Waller.

Of course, that takes on Waller's hammy issues, which is the downside - but the only reason you're getting the offer. I'd assume that risk for the upside.

Kittle was a beast with Purdy last season 

[GobbleDog 984]

3 minutes ago, shorepatrol said:

Kittle was a beast with Purdy last season 

He did and Kittle is a good Te. Just think Waller could provide a bit more consistency and upside, due to situation.