I need aTrade evaluator

[gitrdun 18]

PPR League

Henry and Harrison for Jefferson and Henderson

Who wins???

Thanks guys

[jpcdds 26]

Redraft? Or keeper/dynsty? 

[gitrdun 18]

redraft

 

[jpcdds 26]

Henry/harrison

[Ray_T 780]

3 minutes ago, jpcdds said:

Henry/harrison

this is the correct answer.

I want no part of Jefferson with JJ McCarthy as his starter.  I know Wentz is in there now, so it will be a bit better.   but not better enough.

[LaChup 252]

3 hours ago, jpcdds said:

Redraft? Or keeper/dynsty? 

This^

The answers are obvious, depending on the answer.

[weepaws 3,284]

Henry/Harrison,  Jefferson season  is proving this  that his Qb can make a difference in his ff production 

[JagFan 191]

Jefferson / Henderson.  Henry is starting to slow down and he will continue to fade as the season goes on.  Henderson has finally been elevated to the RB1 in NE, and he’s going to start rolling this weekend.  Harrison will be inconsistent all year, whereas Jefferson’s numbers be steady at a minimum with occasional huge games.

[Sean Mooney 2,042]

Whoever has Jefferson is giving up the best player in the deal. 

The deal is really pretty close because while Jefferson to Harrison is a big downgrade...Henry to Henderson is a big upgrade.

A lot of it depends on what else you have on your roster at the running back and wide receiver positions. 

[Ray_T 780]

3 hours ago, Sean Mooney said:

Whoever has Jefferson is giving up the best player in the deal. 

The deal is really pretty close because while Jefferson to Harrison is a big downgrade...Henry to Henderson is a big upgrade.

A lot of it depends on what else you have on your roster at the running back and wide receiver positions. 

there is no doubt that Jefferson is the best player.   But Jefferson has a QB who likely wont be able to get him the ball.   in redraft that makes him less valuable.    This is a redraft league.

if it was keeper/Dynasty  you'd make that deal to get Jefferson. every time.      Jefferson is on pace to get a bit more than 1000 yards.  by his standards thats not very good.   Hes playing like a WR2.   not his fault.   his rookie QB JJ McCarthy is stinking it up.    So his performance outlook this year is not all that good.   like I said, it might get a bit better with Wentz at QB while McCarthy is out......but not THAT much better. (and possibly worse)

[gitrdun 18]

Would it be different if it was St. Brown instead of Jefferson?

St. Brown and Henderson or Henry and Harrison

[Sean Mooney 2,042]

16 minutes ago, Ray_T said:

there is no doubt that Jefferson is the best player.   But Jefferson has a QB who likely wont be able to get him the ball.   in redraft that makes him less valuable.    This is a redraft league.

if it was keeper/Dynasty  you'd make that deal to get Jefferson. every time.      Jefferson is on pace to get a bit more than 1000 yards.  by his standards thats not very good.   Hes playing like a WR2.   not his fault.   his rookie QB JJ McCarthy is stinking it up.    So his performance outlook this year is not all that good.   like I said, it might get a bit better with Wentz at QB while McCarthy is out......but not THAT much better. (and possibly worse)

I think it's murky regardless of the type of league. Yes McCarthy is hurting Jefferson right now but he's still on pace for like 119 targets....and he's only 26- so he still has value in a dynasty league.

I'm not sure how much Marvin Harrison Jr. can be trusted and he's on pace for the same amount of targets.

Taking last night's numbers out of Harrison's game so we can do 3 to 3 games.

Harrison Jr- 17 targets, 10 catches, 142 yards, 1 touchdown

Jefferson- 20 targets, 12 catches, 200 yards, 1 touchdown

The Henry for Henderson swap is much more of an upgrade dynasty wise almost to the point I'd probably offer that if I were on the getting Henderson side of it. 

[weepaws 3,284]

1 hour ago, gitrdun said:

Would it be different if it was St. Brown instead of Jefferson?

St. Brown and Henderson or Henry and Harrison

St Brown makes it tougher decision, I’m just not sure about Henderson and how he’s going to be used.  But I also agree, I think Henry might be showing us that he’s just human after all.  

I think I would pick St Brown side.  

[Ray_T 780]

8 hours ago, gitrdun said:

Would it be different if it was St. Brown instead of Jefferson?

St. Brown and Henderson or Henry and Harrison

yes, it would (at least for redraft)

St Brown will almost certainly (barring injury) out produce Jefferson this year.