JTB 52 Posted October 14, 2010 all TD's = 6 pts all receptions = 1 p Team A gets: Mendenhall and Big Ben Team B gets: Boldin and A. Peterson What 2 would you prefer with the limited info I supplied. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
BTL99 34 Posted October 14, 2010 Team B without a doubt.............! Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
FeelingMN 273 Posted October 14, 2010 Team B without a doubt.............! x2 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Buttmonkey 8 Posted October 14, 2010 Wow - nicely disguished "help on a trade" thread. Oh, and it's a stupid trade question to begin with - it's obvious which teams gets the better of the trade. So why ask? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
JTB 52 Posted October 14, 2010 Wow - nicely disguished "help on a trade" thread. Oh, and it's a stupid trade question to begin with - it's obvious which teams gets the better of the trade. So why ask? Yawn - Thanks for playing. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
JTB 52 Posted October 14, 2010 Wow - nicely disguished "help on a trade" thread. Oh, and it's a stupid trade question to begin with - it's obvious which teams gets the better of the trade. So why ask? BTW, I didn't ask what team gets the better value from the trade, I asked which YOU would prefer to have. The "other" person in my league liked the Steeler combo better...Hence the trade! Or is that the tandem you think is so obvious? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
the_future420 3 Posted October 14, 2010 BTW, I didn't ask what team gets the better value from the trade, I asked which YOU would prefer to have. The "other" person in my league liked the Steeler combo better...Hence the trade! Or is that the tandem you think is so obvious? Well since its obvious which sides gets the better value its obvious what side anybody would want. This thread is a waste. Its a double waste since it doesn't mean sh!t because we don't know the other players on each roster. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
cbfalcon 824 Posted October 14, 2010 You guys are all idiots. The OP didn't include full rosters because they are clearly inconsequential. That implies each roster aside from these players score the same. Thus you have to take Ben and Mendenhaul over AP and Boldin due to the fact that QB's tend to score so much more than other players. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
PATSSOX 22 Posted October 14, 2010 all TD's = 6 pts all receptions = 1 p Team A gets: Mendenhall and Big Ben Team B gets: Boldin and A. Peterson What 2 would you prefer with the limited info I supplied. With limited info id take AP and Boldin. But if Team A needs a QB then id say Team A. Id say 90% of fantasy people or more would say team B so not a really good question at all. But ill give you a B+ for your effort in dancing around the help board Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Jarvis Basnight 119 Posted October 14, 2010 all TD's = 6 pts all receptions = 1 p Team A gets: Mendenhall and Big Ben Team B gets: Boldin and A. Peterson What 2 would you prefer with the limited info I supplied. I'd want Team A's side because Team A's roster before the trade included.... QB - Moore RB - Chris Johnson WR - M Austin, H Nicks, R White TE - A Gates Team A wins trade and league! Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
JTB 52 Posted October 14, 2010 You guys are all idiots. The OP didn't include full rosters because they are clearly inconsequential. That implies each roster aside from these players score the same. Thus you have to take Ben and Mendenhaul over AP and Boldin due to the fact that QB's tend to score so much more than other players. This is the reason I asked this question. I only gave you the td values and that it is ppr. I know Big Ben is more valuable than any other plater mentioned because he will get 6 pts for his passing td's like a WR or RB will for rushing or receiving and likely Ben will get at least 2-3 passing td's per week. CBFALCON is clearly the winnah in this thread - Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
bsong 0 Posted October 14, 2010 This is the reason I asked this question. I only gave you the td values and that it is ppr. I know Big Ben is more valuable than any other plater mentioned because he will get 6 pts for his passing td's like a WR or RB will for rushing or receiving and likely Ben will get at least 2-3 passing td's per week. CBFALCON is clearly the winnah in this thread - This is flawed logic. Even if a QB got 10 points per touchdown and a RB got 6 points, that wouldn't mean you draft Big Ben ahead of AP. Nor would that make Big Ben automatically the better pickup in the trade. I'll let you and CBFALCON think about it awhile before coming back with the reasoning. But I suspect there are plenty of other readers here who "get it" other than just me. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
PATSSOX 22 Posted October 14, 2010 I'd want Team A's side because Team A's roster before the trade included.... QB - Moore RB - Chris Johnson WR - M Austin, H Nicks, R White TE - A Gates Team A wins trade and league! Good trade for all and yes id rather have team A Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
skinsrule05 30 Posted October 14, 2010 This is flawed logic. Even if a QB got 10 points per touchdown and a RB got 6 points, that wouldn't mean you draft Big Ben ahead of AP. Nor would that make Big Ben automatically the better pickup in the trade. I'll let you and CBFALCON think about it awhile before coming back with the reasoning. But I suspect there are plenty of other readers here who "get it" other than just me. Although under JTBs logic maybe only Big Ben gets 6pts/TD and the rest of the QBs only get 2. Otherwise there is no reason why Big Ben's 2-3 TDs are any more valuable then the other teams QB w/ 2-3 TDs. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
cbfalcon 824 Posted October 14, 2010 My logic was simple. It's not a normal fantasy league that requires all positions to be filled. It's 2 on 2 any positions allowed. Under that scenario, I'd always take a QB. Heck, I'd take 2 QBs if I could. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
khk08 0 Posted October 14, 2010 urgh, why did i waste time reading this thread. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
mobb_deep 919 Posted October 14, 2010 My logic was simple. It's not a normal fantasy league that requires all positions to be filled. It's 2 on 2 any positions allowed. Under that scenario, I'd always take a QB. Heck, I'd take 2 QBs if I could. Couldn't agree more. I'd way rather have Ben Rothelisburger. He throws around 20 receptions per game. That alone is enough of a reason to take him over AP or Boldin. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
PATSSOX 22 Posted October 15, 2010 This is the reason I asked this question. I only gave you the td values and that it is ppr. I know Big Ben is more valuable than any other plater mentioned because he will get 6 pts for his passing td's like a WR or RB will for rushing or receiving and likely Ben will get at least 2-3 passing td's per week. CBFALCON is clearly the winnah in this thread - There is no winnah in this thread you all lose http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VDW0ZnZxjn4 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
