Donald Brown trade. Commish needs help!

[ryno486 0]

I traded Steve Johnson for Donald Brown on Monday. I am the commish of this league. Can this trade be reversed due to the fact that Donald Brown was injured before the trade offer was made and now it is a completely lopsided trade. I am in a pickle, since I am the loser and the commish in this deal. Remember the news did not come out until yesterday. Please offer suggestions.

[Roadrunner1 1]

I would say sorry for you but a trade is a trade.

[montana 89]

Doesn't matter when news was made available. It was offered, you accepted. End of story. Yes it sucks, but you have got to let it stand to establish/maintain your integrity.

 

Signed,

Commish

since 1995

[JML7211 0]

No. You can't. What if Steve Johnson gets hurt sunday? Then do you re-reverse the trade. Injuries go into the trade equation. Yes, timing is awful but that would be total BS if you reversed this.

[jgcrawfish 232]

sorry, but the trade stays.

[Ditka vs. ______ 0]

Doesn't matter when news was made available. It was offered, you accepted. End of story. Yes it sucks, but you have got to let it stand to establish/maintain your integrity.

 

+1

[ryno486 0]

Okay, just really sucks a big one. I knew this was probably going to have to stand. Gotta love Fantasy Football.

[Jetdoc 20]

If I were in your league and the commissioner reversed this trade, I would demand my money back immediately.

[murf74 461]

I would say sorry for you but a trade is a trade.

Yep

[travis_henrys_baby_momma 10]

Don't worry, Donald Brown will be back in 3 weeks.....toting Vick Ballard's water bottle.

[CedarGrovePack 2]

I traded Steve Johnson for Donald Brown on Monday. I am the commish of this league. Can this trade be reversed due to the fact that Donald Brown was injured before the trade offer was made and now it is a completely lopsided trade. I am in a pickle, since I am the loser and the commish in this deal. Remember the news did not come out until yesterday. Please offer suggestions.

 

 

tough luck. go get Ballard

[ryno486 0]

tough luck. go get Ballard

 

He already got Ballard too...

[unclemercy 51]

funny question.

[TD Ryan2 314]

I traded Steve Johnson for Donald Brown on Monday. I am the commish of this league. Can this trade be reversed due to the fact that Donald Brown was injured before the trade offer was made and now it is a completely lopsided trade. I am in a pickle, since I am the loser and the commish in this deal. Remember the news did not come out until yesterday. Please offer suggestions.

you made the trade. you are stuck with it.

The ONLY reason any trade should ever be vetoed is if collusion is involved - the fact that it is lopsided doesn't matter, and the fact that it is lopsided b/c a guy was injured matters even less.

 

As the commish of the league, this is actually a good thing for you - by allowing the trade, you set the precedent for all those in your league and can stand by it especially since you were the "loser" in a deal.

 

The old, "he traded me an injured player and I didn't know it" just doesn't cut it - it is your responsibility to look into players health/status before you pick or trade-for them - and if there was no negative news/etc, still doesn't matter.

[DamageIncVacc 6]

Yeah

 

This happened in my league a few years ago. I traded Germane Crowell for someone (Was a long time ago, cant remember) and 5 minutes later they announced that Crowell had broken his leg and was out for the year. I did offer to reverse it because it was a friends league BUT commish said no a trade is a trade. On the [positive atleast Brown will be back in 3 weeks.

[Quickolas1 80]

if I was in this league, it would worry me that a commish thought this was even a consideration

[Laurence Maroney's Nuts 2]

You should get punched in the face for even considering this question.

[BarackOdrama 0]

You, as the commissioner, shouldn't be considering this. Let somebody else commish.

[dain11279 928]

You should get punched in the face for even considering this question.

 

This.

 

And it was a dumb trade to begin with. You have been charged with stupidity on numerous counts

[Dashow28 6]

He already got Ballard too...

 

^LOL! Sorry dude, but that's hilarious.

[SexyRexy 60]

I traded Steve Johnson for Donald Brown on Monday. I am the commish of this league. Can this trade be reversed due to the fact that Donald Brown was injured before the trade offer was made and now it is a completely lopsided trade. I am in a pickle, since I am the loser and the commish in this deal. Remember the news did not come out until yesterday. Please offer suggestions.

 

nope..you cant reverse a trade under those conditions. trade has to stand.

[mgs316 14]

I can't believe you seriously asked this question, are you a fricken moron? How in any way can you even justify asking this question?

[mgs316 14]

You should get punched in the face for even considering this question.

 

That is getting off too light. Seriously, one of the single dumbest questions ever offered on this bored.